Dangerous neighbours: Birds and bird‐eating bats sharing tree cavities

Danilo Russo,Anne Mäenurm,Adriano Martinoli,Luca Cistrone

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.11098

IF: 3.167

2024-03-13

Ecology and Evolution

Abstract:Greater noctules feed on birds, including Eurasian blue tits, with the presumed strategy being in‐flight capture, yet no direct observations confirming this holds true. We recorded the successful nesting of blue tits in a tree cavity shared with around 25 greater noctules and recorded no predatory interactions over the whole nesting period. Our observation supports the hypothesis that roosting bats are not perceived as a threat, indirectly endorsing the 'aerial hawking' predation theory. Mounting evidence indicates the non‐consumptive effects of predators significantly impact prey physiology, ecology and behaviour. Passerine birds experience adverse effects on nesting and reproductive success when in proximity to predators. Fear of predators is context‐dependent and influenced by hunting habitats and foraging strategies. While some bat species prey on birds, the greater noctule (Nyctalus lasiopterus) stands out by specialising in avian prey, especially during peak bird migration. N. lasiopterus is thought to seize avian prey in flight, but direct evidence is lacking. If birds were taken from nests, they would likely avoid nesting near these bats. However, no observations support this view. This study documents the successful reproduction of Eurasian blue tits (Cyanistes caeruleus) nesting alongside a colony of approximately 25 greater noctules. This bird species is a prey species for greater noctules in Italy. Over about 1 month (April–May 2023), we observed parent birds provisioning food to chicks, with at least two chicks alive and fed outside the tree cavity by the end of the period. While acknowledging the limitations of a single observation, we propose that this previously unknown behaviour indirectly supports the idea that greater noctules only capture avian prey in flight, not within confined spaces. This observation challenges the perception that these bats pose a threat when sharing roosting spaces in trees, as evidenced in our observed case. We hope this novel observation inspires future research on variations in bird nesting behaviour and reproductive success in the presence of bird‐eating bats, as well as an assessment of the long‐term impact on population dynamics and reproductive success of nesting birds sharing such roosting spaces.

ecology,evolutionary biology