What Makes Weak Ties Strong?

Minjae Kim,Roberto M. Fernandez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-soc-030921-034152

IF: 10.5

2023-03-21

Annual Review of Sociology

Abstract:We raise two challenges concerning the validity of arguments underlying Granovetter's strength of weak ties (SWT) thesis: ( a) whether weak ties are actually bridges, i.e., they help reach more socially distant actors than strong ties, and ( b) whether weak ties transmit information effectively enough so that weak ties’ alleged structural properties make them more useful than strong ties. In the course of reviewing subsequent research that has made progress in addressing these challenges, we identify both potential limits and possibilities for the SWT thesis. We argue for the importance of identifying how actors’ agency—i.e., the way people use their ties—may affect social networks’ value. We conclude by summarizing some outstanding questions that progress on the SWT thesis has generated. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Sociology, Volume 49 is July 2023. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.

sociology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore and question the validity of Granovetter's "Strength of Weak Ties" (SWT) theory. Specifically, the article poses two main challenges:

1. **Are weak ties indeed bridges?** That is, whether weak ties actually help people reach social groups that are more distant than those reached through strong ties. Weak ties are considered as bridges connecting different social circles, enabling individuals to obtain non - redundant information.

2. **Can weak ties effectively transmit information?** Even if weak ties play a bridging role structurally, can they effectively transmit information, making these structural features more useful than strong ties?

#### Specific problems

- **Are weak ties necessarily bridges?** The paper explores whether weak ties necessarily have a bridging role or whether this assumption is overly simplistic. The author points out that weak ties may not be the only or the most effective bridges, and strong ties may also connect individuals at a greater social distance.

- **The information - transmitting ability of weak ties** The paper questions whether weak ties can transmit information without hindrance. Although weak ties may connect different social circles, there may be obstacles when they transmit information. For example, information transmission is not automatic, and the bridging characteristics of weak ties may make information transmission more difficult.

#### Research progress and future directions

The article reviews the research progress on these two challenges over the past 50 years and points out the limitations of existing research and the directions for future research. The author emphasizes the importance of actor agency, that is, how people use their relationship networks, which may affect the value of the network. In addition, the author believes that although the structural characteristics of weak ties may be a necessary condition for information diffusion, they are not necessarily sufficient, so it is necessary to consider how people make use of these relationships.

In conclusion, through the exploration of the above two challenges, this paper re - examines the validity of the SWT theory and provides new perspectives and directions for future research.