Perception of experience influences altruism and perception of agency influences trust in human–machine interactions

Mayada Oudah,Kinga Makovi,Kurt Gray,Balaraju Battu,Talal Rahwan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-63360-w
IF: 4.6
2024-05-31
Scientific Reports
Abstract:As robots become increasingly integrated into social economic interactions, it becomes crucial to understand how people perceive a robot's mind. It has been argued that minds are perceived along two dimensions: experience, i.e., the ability to feel, and agency, i.e., the ability to act and take responsibility for one's actions. However, the influence of these perceived dimensions on human–machine interactions, particularly those involving altruism and trust, remains unknown. We hypothesize that the perception of experience influences altruism, while the perception of agency influences trust. To test these hypotheses, we pair participants with bot partners in a dictator game (to measure altruism) and a trust game (to measure trust) while varying the bots' perceived experience and agency, either by manipulating the degree to which the bot resembles humans, or by manipulating the description of the bots' ability to feel and exercise self-control. The results demonstrate that the money transferred in the dictator game is influenced by the perceived experience, while the money transferred in the trust game is influenced by the perceived agency, thereby confirming our hypotheses. More broadly, our findings support the specificity of the mind hypothesis: Perceptions of different dimensions of the mind lead to different kinds of social behavior.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to explore how human cognition of machine mind (experience and agency) affects human altruistic behavior and trust when interacting with machines. Specifically, the researchers hypothesize that the perception of a machine's experiential capacity influences human altruistic behavior, while the perception of a machine's agency capacity affects human trust. To test these hypotheses, the study measures participants' responses to different types of robots in a series of experiments using the dictator game (to measure altruistic behavior) and the trust game (to measure trust). The robots' perceived experience and agency were manipulated by altering their appearance from highly mechanical to highly humanoid. The results indicate that in the dictator game, perceived experience significantly influenced the amount of money transferred; whereas in the trust game, perceived agency significantly influenced the amount of money transferred, thus supporting the researchers' hypotheses. Additionally, the study further manipulated the robots' experiential and agency attributes through textual descriptions to rule out other variables, ultimately demonstrating the causal relationship between perceived experience and perceived agency on altruistic behavior and trust, respectively. This finding not only reveals the specific impact of mind perception on social behavior but also provides a theoretical basis for designing robots that better facilitate human-machine interaction in the future.