A pilot study of measuring emotional response and perception of LLM-generated questionnaire and human-generated questionnaires

Zhao Zou,Omar Mubin,Fady Alnajjar,Luqman Ali
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-53255-1
IF: 4.6
2024-02-03
Scientific Reports
Abstract:The advent of ChatGPT has sparked a heated debate surrounding natural language processing technology and AI-powered chatbots, leading to extensive research and applications across various disciplines. This pilot study aims to investigate the impact of ChatGPT on users' experiences by administering two distinct questionnaires, one generated by humans and the other by ChatGPT, along with an Emotion Detecting Model. A total of 14 participants (7 female and 7 male) aged between 18 and 35 years were recruited, resulting in the collection of 8672 ChatGPT-associated data points and 8797 human-associated data points. Data analysis was conducted using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA). The results indicate that the utilization of ChatGPT enhances participants' happiness levels and reduces their sadness levels. While no significant gender influences were observed, variations were found about specific emotions. It is important to note that the limited sample size, narrow age range, and potential cultural impacts restrict the generalizability of the findings to a broader population. Future research directions should explore the impact of incorporating additional language models or chatbots on user emotions, particularly among specific age groups such as older individuals and teenagers. As one of the pioneering works evaluating the human perception of ChatGPT text and communication, it is noteworthy that ChatGPT received positive evaluations and demonstrated effectiveness in generating extensive questionnaires.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Aims to Address This paper aims to explore the impact of questionnaires generated by ChatGPT versus those generated by humans on users' emotions and perceptions. Specifically, the researchers hope to evaluate the effectiveness of ChatGPT in academic research by comparing the two different sources of questionnaires, particularly its impact on users' emotions. #### Main Research Questions: 1. **Emotional Impact**: Can questionnaires generated by ChatGPT enhance users' happiness and reduce sadness? 2. **Gender Differences**: Are there significant differences in emotional responses between male and female users when facing questionnaires generated by ChatGPT? 3. **User Perception**: How do users evaluate questionnaires generated by ChatGPT overall? Are these questionnaires more popular compared to those generated by humans? #### Research Background: - **Technological Background**: With the development of natural language processing (NLP) technology, especially the emergence of AI chatbots like ChatGPT, these technologies are increasingly being applied in various fields such as education, healthcare, and cybersecurity. - **Emotion Recognition**: Researchers have conducted extensive studies on the emotion recognition capabilities of AI chatbots, finding that these bots can provide more supportive and interactive conversations by recognizing users' emotions. - **User Experience**: Understanding the emotional changes users experience during interactions with AI chatbots is crucial for improving human-computer interaction experiences. #### Research Motivation: - **AI Proliferation**: As AI chatbots become more widely used, understanding their impact on user experience becomes particularly important. - **Emotional Interaction**: Studying the emotional impact of ChatGPT when generating questionnaires can help develop more friendly and empathetic AI solutions. #### Research Methods: - **Participants**: 14 participants aged 18 to 35 were recruited (7 females and 7 males). - **Questionnaire Design**: Two identical questionnaires were designed, one generated by humans and the other by ChatGPT. - **Emotion Detection**: An emotion detection model was used to record participants' emotional changes while filling out the questionnaires. - **Data Analysis**: Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used for statistical analysis of the data to evaluate the impact of different questionnaires on users' emotions. #### Main Findings: - **Emotional Changes**: Questionnaires generated by ChatGPT significantly enhanced participants' happiness and reduced their sadness. - **Gender Differences**: Female participants showed higher sensitivity to questionnaires generated by ChatGPT, especially in terms of happiness. - **User Evaluation**: Questionnaires generated by ChatGPT received positive evaluations, indicating their potential in generating complex questionnaires. Through this study, the authors hope to provide a reference for future research, further exploring the application effects of AI chatbots in different age groups and specific populations.