The Effects of a Badminton Content Knowledge Workshop on Middle School Physical Education Teachers' Pedagogical Content Knowledge and Student Learning

Insook Kim

Abstract:A majority of studies have argued that content knowledge (CK) is related to the development of pedagogical content knowledge (PCK). Yet few studies have examined this relationship directly. Moreover, many of the studies have not functionally identified what PCK is, and under what conditions PCK develops. In the absence of a functional definition of PCK, there has been a significant problem in discussing and using PCK in research and in practice (Amade-Escot, 2000). Ward’s (2010) definition of PCK has allowed researchers to observe and measure PCK; however, several questions remain unanswered relative to PCK. The most important are: “Is there a causal relationship (a) between CK and PCK; and (b) between PCK and student achievement?” These questions can be answered using experimental analysis only by manipulating the level of teachers’ CK to determine if there are changes in teachers’ PCK and subsequent changes in student learning. Therefore, the purpose of the study was to investigate the effects of a CK workshop on teachers’ PCK and student achievement in a badminton unit. A quasi-experimental design with two middle school PE teachers as a block was used to examine the change of teachers’ teaching behaviors and student learning behaviors in their intact classes before and after a badminton CK workshop in a natural PE setting. The subsequent teachers’ PCK variables were measured by a video analysis method: the maturity of task representation, the appropriateness of task selection, and the adaptations of tasks between and within the tasks. For the students’ performance data, students’ correct and incorrect trials on skills and tactics and other trials (i.e., unfair opportunity, missed opportunity, and non-target performance) were measured using a live coding method during practice and game play. For the analysis of teachers’ dependent variables, descriptive statistics (i.e., means and ranges) were used for both the comparison and the experimental classes. For the analysis of students’ dependent variables, descriptive statistics (i.e., means and ranges) and inferential statistics (i.e., non-parametric tests) were used for both the comparison and the experimental classes. The results of the descriptive and inferential statistics on student data showed that the improved teachers’ PCK as a function of CK influence the increase of student’s correct trials and the decrease of students’ incorrect trials in badminton. The results of the descriptive analysis of teachers’ data showed that teachers’ PCK variables including task maturity, task appropriateness and task adaptations can be changed from immature to mature as a function of teachers’ CK. The findings of the study suggest that the teacher education programs for preservice and inservice teachers should improve teacher’s CK with specific practices and relevant and specific feedback on teaching that influences teachers’ PCK and student learning.

Computer Science,Education