Abstract:Hierarchies are a ubiquitous form of human social organization. We hypothesized that 1 reason for the prevalence of hierarchies is that they offer structure and therefore satisfy the core motivational needs for order and control relative to less structured forms of social organization. This hypothesis is rooted in compensatory control theory, which posits that (a) individuals have a basic need to perceive the world as orderly and structured, and (b) personal and external sources of control are capable of satisfying this need because both serve the comforting belief that the world operates in an orderly fashion. Our first 2 studies confirmed that hierarchies were perceived as more structured and orderly relative to egalitarian arrangements (Study 1) and that working in a hierarchical workplace promotes a feeling of self-efficacy (Study 2). We threatened participants' sense of personal control and measured perceptions of and preferences for hierarchy in 5 subsequent experiments. Participants who lacked control perceived more hierarchy occurring in ambiguous social situations (Study 3) and preferred hierarchy more strongly in workplace contexts (Studies 4-5). We also provide evidence that hierarchies are indeed appealing because of their structure: Preference for hierarchy was higher among individuals high in Personal Need for Structure and a control threat increased preference for hierarchy even among participants low in Personal Need for Structure (Study 5). Framing a hierarchy as unstructured reversed the effect of control threat on hierarchy (Study 6). Finally, hierarchy-enhancing jobs were more appealing after control threat, even when they were low in power and status (Study 7).

ASSOCIATION FOR CONSUMER RESEARCH The Beauty of Boundaries: When and Why We Seek Structure in Consumption

The pursuit of optimal distinctiveness and consumer preferences.

How Time Horizon Perceptions and Relationship Deficits Affect Impulsive Consumption

Inherently Loyal or Easily Bored?: Nonconscious Activation of Consistency Versus Variety-Seeking Behavior

The consumer–activity relationship and separation distress

Asserting Your Mind: Interruptions Extremize Consumer Choices

Values and Behavior: Strength and Structure of Relations

ASSOCIATION FOR CONSUMER RESEARCH Fooling Yourself: the Role of Internal Defense Mechanisms in Unsustainable Consumption Behavior

The Impact of Identity Breadth on Consumer Preference for Advanced Products

Consumer Research: In Search of Identity

Creating Boundary-Breaking, Marketing-Relevant Consumer Research

Self-control and sustainability consumption: Findings from a cross cultural study

Strong versus weak consumer‐brand relationships: Matching psychological sense of brand community and type of advertising appeal

Seeking structure in social organization: Compensatory control and the psychological advantages of hierarchy.

Maintaining the order: How social crowding promotes minimalistic consumption practice

Collective consciousness and consumer behavior

Consumer–Company Identification: A Framework for Understanding Consumers’ Relationships with Companies

How Positive and Negative Emotions Promote Ritualistic Consumption Through Different Mechanisms

Consumer Research Insights on Brands and Branding: A JCR Curation

Inner-Self Vs. Outer-Self and Socially Responsible Product Consumption