Abstract:Understanding how landscape characteristics such as matrix composition and configuration affect bird movement is essential for conservation in human-disturbed habitats. An important tool for such studies is experimental translocation, in which birds are removed from their territories, and observed, often using radio telemetry, as to whether they return (“home”). Here we reviewed 28 translocation studies to investigate (1) in what regions and habitats, and with what species the technique has been used, (2) what proportion of birds fail to home, a measure of “bird safety”, (3) the findings the studies have uncovered about bird movement, and (4) how the studies have dealt with confounding variables. A phylogenetically controlled meta-analysis complemented the qualitative results, testing the effects of the species’ habitat usage and migration ecology on the difference between birds’ homing success when moving through contiguous forest as compared to other land-use types. Of the total sample, 25 studies were conducted in the Western Hemisphere, and 17 in locations where pasturelands were the dominant land-use. The technique has been mostly used with small, forest-preferring passerine species, and males. Regarding safety, the proportion of individuals that failed to home was 27.1 ± 21.8 (SD)%. Translocation distance was found to be an important predictor of homing time or success in seven studies. The meta-analysis confirmed that on average birds move better through contiguous forests than through other land-use types, with habitat generalists and species with seasonal migration having less trouble moving through disturbed land-use types. The qualitative analyses also demonstrated the importance of habitat usage, with forest specialists especially affected by forest cover and connectivity. In considering the utility of translocations, it is important to remember that they are not measuring juvenile dispersal, and the birds’ homing mechanisms might influence their movements. However, long-distance translocations can avoid homing and hence simulate breeding (adult) dispersal. The confounding effects of variation among capture and release sites, or among individuals in their physiological condition, must be carefully considered. Overall, experimental translocation is a mature technique for which possible pitfalls have been identified. Strengths of the approach are that bird motivations to move can be standardized, and fine-scale movement patterns can be described with telemetry. However, we encourage consideration of bird safety, and meticulous reporting of birds that fail to home, or fail to find suitable habitat in long-distance translocation designs.

Habitat preferences and survival in wildlife reintroductions: an ecological trap in reintroduced grey partridges

Identifying mismatches between habitat selection and habitat quality in a ground‐nesting farmland bird

Maladaptive Habitat Selection of a Migratory Passerine Bird in a Human-Modified Landscape

Diet complexity in early life affects survival in released pheasants by altering foraging efficiency, food choice, handling skills and gut morphology.

Habitat selection and behaviour of a reintroduced passerine: linking experimental restoration, behaviour and habitat ecology

The conservation island effect of commercial hunting of red-legged partridges (Alectoris rufa) in agricultural landscapes

Use of linear features by red-legged partridges in an intensive agricultural landscape: implications for landscape management in farmland

Comparing Post-Release Survival and Habitat Use by Captive-Bred Cabot’s Tragopan（Tragopan Caboti） in an Experimental Test of Soft-Release Reintroduction Strategies

Be nimble with threat mitigation: lessons learned from the reintroduction of an endangered species

Discerning the status of a rapidly declining naturalised bird: the Golden Pheasant in Britain

Do habitat preferences improve fitness? Context-specific adaptive habitat selection by a grassland songbird

A Review of Avian Experimental Translocations That Measure Movement Through Human-Modified Landscapes

Conservation Interventions Are Required to Improve Bird Breeding Performance in Artificial Wetlands

Personality, sex and capture biases: Challenges for predator monitoring and management

Reed Parrotbill Nest Predation by Tidal Mudflat Crabs: Evidence for an Ecological Trap?

Local sub‐population dynamics of a central European grey partridge meta‐population support large‐scale conservation approach to halt its ongoing decline

Comparison of pesticide contamination between captive-reared and wild grey partridges: insights into environmental exposure disparities

Understanding stakeholder perceptions on the impacts of gamebird releasing on or near UK protected sites

Multi‐scale habitat selection and nest survival of whinchats and stonechats: implications for grassland conservation management

Conflicting and complementary ethics of animal welfare considerations in reintroductions

The effect of small-scale agro-environmental initiatives on avian diversity in agricultural landscapes