Demographic Transition in the Netherlands: A Statistical Analysis of Regional Differences in the Level and Development of the Birth Rate and of Fertility, 1850-1890

O.W.A. Boonstra,A. M. V. D. Woude
Abstract:Multivariate and causal analyses of the effects of 6 variables on the level and development of the Dutch birth rate between 1850 and 1890 help to explain the process of demographic transition in the Netherlands. Scholarly opinion has been divided about the influence of religion and the influence of regionally divergent attitudes on the process of modernization. In statistical analyses of 375 Dutch municipalities use is made of 6 variables that are indicators of geographic demographic economic and sociocultural phenomena. The preponderant weight of the purely demographic variable (death rate) stands out clearly. In every case the level and fall of the death rate showed the greatest correlation with the level and development of the birth rate. Regarding level of birth rate analyses showed the positive influence of economic (immigration surplus) cultural-geographic (agricultural systems as indicators of diverging attitudes) and cultural (religion and until 1871 illiteracy) variables. The geographic variable of population density showed no noticeable effect on level of birth rate. Before 1890 the regional factor was of much greater importance for the demographic transition process than the religious (Dutch Roman Catholicism) one. However in a later phase of the process (after 1900) the religious variable may have gained momentum and overtaken the regional explanation. In the analysis of the static situation (level of birth rate) religion played a slightly more decisive role in restraining birth rates than did the clay-sand distinction (agricultural systems). In the analysis of the dynamics (development of the birth rate) religion played no role. It seems that regional (geographically bounded patterns of culture have been decisive in the process of demographic transition in the Netherlands.
History,Sociology,Geography
What problem does this paper attempt to address?