Abstract:Efficient error estimates for the Trotter product formula are central in quantum computing, mathematical physics, and numerical simulations. However, the Trotter error's dependency on the input state and its application to unbounded operators remains unclear. Here, we present a general theory for error estimation, including higher-order product formulas, with explicit input state dependency. Our approach overcomes two limitations of the existing operator-norm estimates in the literature. First, previous bounds are too pessimistic as they quantify the worst-case scenario. Second, previous bounds become trivial for unbounded operators and cannot be applied to a wide class of Trotter scenarios, including atomic and molecular Hamiltonians. Our method enables analytical treatment of Trotter errors in chemistry simulations, illustrated through a case study on the hydrogen atom. Our findings reveal: (i) for states with fat-tailed energy distribution, such as low-angular-momentum states of the hydrogen atom, the Trotter error scales worse than expected (sublinearly) in the number of Trotter steps; (ii) certain states do not admit an advantage in the scaling from higher-order Trotterization, and thus, the higher-order Trotter hierarchy breaks down for these states, including the hydrogen atom's ground state; (iii) the scaling of higher-order Trotter bounds might depend on the order of the Hamiltonians in the Trotter product for states with fat-tailed energy distribution. Physically, the enlarged Trotter error is caused by the atom's ionization due to the Trotter dynamics. Mathematically, we find that certain domain conditions are not satisfied by some states so higher moments of the potential and kinetic energies diverge. Our analytical error analysis agrees with numerical simulations, indicating that we can estimate the state-dependent Trotter error scaling genuinely.

Comment on 'Solving a singular integral equation for the one-dimensional Coulomb problem' (2023 Physica Scripta 98 085219)

Solution of the momentum-space Schrödinger equation for bound states of the N-dimensional Coulomb problem (revisited)

Integral equation approach for a hydrogen atom in a strong magnetic field

The energy level structure of the modified Schrodinger equation can be consistent with Lamb shift

Comment on "A single level tunneling model for molecular junctions: evaluating the simulation methods" by E. M. Opodi, X. Song, X. Yu and W. Hu, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. , 2022, 24 , 11958"

Comment on "Unified framework for open quantum dynamics with memory"

Some remarks on Coulombic effects in and scattering and the determination of

Comment on "Solutions of Schrodinger equation for the modified Mobius square plus Kratzer potential"

Collisionless hydrodynamics for 1D motion of inhomogeneous degenerate electron gases: equivalence of two recent descriptions

Comment on: "Analytical solutions to the Schrödinger equation for a generalized Cornell potential and its applications to diatomic molecules and heavy mesons"

Disfavoring the Schroedinger-Newton equation

Unified analysis of finite-size error for periodic Hartree-Fock and second order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory

Revisiting the Laplace Transform in Quantum Mechanics: Correcting a Flawed Approach for the Stationary Schrödinger Equation

A note on accurate pressure calculations of Coulomb systems with periodic boundary conditions

Strong Error Bounds for Trotter & Strang-Splittings and Their Implications for Quantum Chemistry

Solution to the Balitsky-Kovchegov equation with the collinearly improved kernel including impact-parameter dependence

Homogeneous and Inhomogeneous Formulations of Nonrelativistic Potential Scattering

The Derivation of the Compressible Euler Equation from Quantum Many-Body Dynamics

Analytical Expression for Continuum-continuum Transition Amplitude of Hydrogen-like Atoms with Angular-momentum Dependence

Comment on "A single level tunneling model for molecular junctions: evaluating the simulation methods" by Opodi et al