Abstract:BackgroundStudents and teachers in twenty-first century STEM classrooms face significant challenges in preparing for post-secondary education, career, and citizenship. Educators have advocated for student-centered instruction as a way to face these challenges, with multiple programs emerging to shape and define such contexts. However, the ways to support teachers as they transition into non-traditional teaching must be developed. The purpose of this study is to explore the impacts on educators of teaching in student-centered, peer-mediated STEM classrooms and preparing student peer leaders for their roles in these classes. Research questions examined how teachers think about themselves as they implement student-centered pedagogy, the difficulties they face as their roles and identities shift, and the ways they grow or resist growth. Qualitative research conducted at two urban secondary schools documents the diverse experiences and responses of teachers in an innovative, student-centered STEM instructional program. The experiences and perceptions of 13 STEM teachers illuminate the possibilities and challenges for teachers in student-centered classrooms.ResultsAll participating teachers described multiple benefits of teaching in a student-centered classroom and differences from traditional classrooms. Their transitions to this type of teaching fell into three major categories based upon past identities and current beliefs. Some teachers found the pedagogy consistent with preexisting identities and embraced it without radical change to their concepts of teaching. They described ways in which the model helped them become the teachers they had always wanted to be. Other teachers, who initially identified as deliverers of STEM content, had more difficult experiences adjusting to student-centered instruction. In one case, a teacher resisted change and exited the program, maintaining her identity and deciding not to become student-centered. Other participating teachers made dramatic shifts in their identities in order to implement the program. These teachers described significant learning curves as they shared responsibility for student learning with student leaders.ConclusionsThis study suggests that radically changing the learning environment can affect teachers’ identities and their approaches to teaching in predictable ways that can inform teacher education and professional development programs for STEM teachers, maximizing the success of teachers as they implement student-centered pedagogy.

Generative Paradox in Learner-Centered College Teaching

Constructing and Reconstructing Teaching Roles: A focus on generative metaphors and dichotomies

Understanding pragmatic paradoxes: When contradictions become paralyzing and what to do about it

Paradigms extended: how to integrate behaviorism, constructivism, knowledge domain, and learner mastery in instructional design

The Learning Spiral: A Process Perspective on Paradox

Paradoxical Education: Learning to Unlearn What We Think We Have Learned

Complexity, Struggle, and the Dialogical Self: Learning from New Teachers to Shift the Paradigm of Teacher Education and Professional Learning

Exploring Contradiction‐Driven Language Teacher Identity Transformation During Curriculum Reforms: A Chinese Tale

How Do Leaders Cope with the Paradoxical Situations? the Development of Paradoxical Leadership

Contrasting stances at the crossroads of debugging learning opportunities

Paradoxes in Organizational Change: The Crucial Role of Leaders’ Sensegiving

Faculty – Graduate teaching assistant mentoring model: Chaos theory in action

Teaching Transgressive Representations of LGBTQ People in Educator Preparation: Is Conformity Required for Inclusion?

Shared Philosophies, Conflict, and Critical Reflection: Developing Productive Teacher Collaboration

Dancing on the Razor’s Edge: How Top-Level Women Leaders Manage the Paradoxical Tensions between Agency and Communion

The Dual Paradox and Beyond in Teaching Harmony and Conflict：On the Educational Implication of Teaching Conflict

Reconstructing the paradigm: teaching across the disciplines

Deep Thinking or Resistance? On Finding a Middle Ground between Paolo Freire’s Critical Pedagogy and John Dewey’s Pragmatism

Student-centered Education and Constructivism: Challenges, Concerns, and Clarity for Teachers

Teachers’ roles and identities in student-centered classrooms

Complicating methods for understanding educators’ language ideologies: transformative approaches for mixing methods