Theoretical reconstruction of Galileo's two-bucket experiment

Sylvio R. Bistafa
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1806.06281
2018-06-16
History and Philosophy of Physics
Abstract:In the present work, we address the solution of a problem extracted from a historical context, in which Galileo supposedly conducted an experiment to measure the percussion force of a water jet. To this end, the conservation equations of fluid mechanics in unsteady state are employed in the theoretical reconstruction of the experiment. The experimental apparatus consists of a balance, in which a counterweight hangs on to one of its extremities, and two buckets, in the same vertical, hang on to the other extremity. The water jet issuing from an orifice in the bottom of the upper bucket strikes the lower bucket. The objective is to find the jet percussion force on the lower bucket. The result of the analysis revealed that the method proposed by Galileo for the calculation of the jet percussion force is incorrect. The analysis also revealed that the resultant force during the process is practically null, which would make Galileo's account of the major movements of the balance credible, despite his having not identified all the forces acting on the system.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?