Neoclassical economics and principles of sustainable development

Robert Goodland,George Ledec

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-3800(87)90043-3

IF: 3.1

1987-09-01

Ecological Modelling

Abstract:This paper reviews the principal policy-related issues for which the professions of ecology and economics provide conflicting prescriptions. Emphasis is placed on the work of the World Bank, although the issues raised are relevant to a broad range of organizations. Rather than providing definitive solutions, the paper suggests an agenda for research in the ecology-economics interface.Present-day neoclassical economic theory and its applications to development policy seriously overlook or undervalue major ecological concerns. The economic values of environmental services, while very real, are systematically underestimated in cost-benefit analysis because of measurement and valuation difficulties. ‘Intangible’ environmental benefits, such as those derived from the preservation of biological diversity, are recognized even less in economic analysis. The irreversible environmental effects of projects or policies are usually treated no differently from more reversible effects. The practice of discounting economic costs and benefits strongly favors projects with short-term benefits and long-term costs, often (though not always) with highly negative environmental effects. Using Gross National Product as a measure of development progress encourages rapid overexploitation of a country's natural resource base. Extravagant natural resource consumption by industrialized countries may undermine long-term development prospects of developing countries. The emphasis of many developing countries on export crops rather than domestic food production often entails major environmental costs.The paper outlines some of the principles of ecologically sustainable development. At the project level, safe minimum standards are an important environmental supplement to cost-benefit analysis. At the national policy level, steady-state economics can be used to reconcile economic planning with the limits to growth in natural resource consumption.

ecology