Abstract:Using circular bio-based building materials is considered a promising solution to reduce the environmental impacts of the construction industry. To identify the pros and cons of these materials, it is essential to investigate their sustainability performance. However, the previous sustainability assessment studies are heterogeneous regarding the assessment methods and objectives, highlighting the need for a review to identify and analyse these aspects. Moreover, there is still a lack of studies reviewing the methodological issues and implications of the assessment methods, as well as the current end-of-life scenarios and circularity options for these materials. To address these gaps, this study conducts a systematic and critical review of a sample of 97 articles. The results indicate that Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) is the most frequently applied method, yet most studies are cradle-to-gate analyses of materials. Otherwise, very few studies consider the end-of-life phase, and most of the end-of-life scenarios analysed are unsustainable and have low circularity levels. The analysis also highlights the methodological issues of the assessment methods used, with a particular focus on LCA, such as a lack of consensus on system boundaries, functional units, and databases for facilitating sustainability assessments associated with the use of circular bio-based building materials. Two primary recommendations emerge from the analysis. Firstly, for LCA studies, it is recommended to increase transparency and harmonisation in assessments to improve the comparability of results. Besides, to overcome data availability issues, it is recommended to use data from multiple sources and conduct sensitivity and uncertainty analyses. Secondly, more sustainability assessments (including the three pillars) considering the whole life cycle with more sustainable end-of-life scenarios and circularity options for these materials should be conducted.

Assessing the circularity and sustainability of circular carpets — a demonstration of circular life cycle sustainability assessment

Circular life cycle sustainability assessment: An integrated framework

An analysis of design strategies for circular economy through life cycle assessment

Design issues concerning circular economy assessment methods at the product level: a comparative analysis through a case study of a mobile tiny house

Combining Building Information Model and Life Cycle Assessment for Defining Circular Economy Strategies

Life cycle assessment applications to reuse, recycling and circular practices for textiles: A review

Life cycle assessment of a circular textile value chain: the case of a garment made from chemically recycled cotton

A breakthrough in circular economy: Using a closed-loop framework to assess the circularity of supply chains

A customized multi-cycle model for measuring the sustainability of circular pathways in agri-food supply chains

Exploring the Missing Link between Life Cycle Assessment and Circularity Assessment in the Built Environment

Life cycle assessment and circularity indicators

Sustainability assessment methods for circular bio-based building materials: A literature review

Circular product design assessment applied to clothing products

Synergies and gaps between circularity assessment and Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Integrating circular economy and sustainability assessment on the micro-level: An umbrella review

Assessment of Circular Economy Development in the EU Countries Based on SAW Method

Textiles on the Path to Sustainability and Circularity—Results of Application Tests in the Business-to-Business Sector

Assessing scaling effects of circular economy strategies: A case study on plastic bottle closed-loop recycling in the USA PET market

Sustainable Agri-Food Processes and Circular Economy Pathways in a Life Cycle Perspective: State of the Art of Applicative Research

Life cycle assessment and circular practices in the woodworking sector: a systematic review

Sustainability, the Circular Economy and Digitalisation in the German Textile and Clothing Industry