Abstract:The Circular Economy is a contemporary and popular concept that describes how materials and resources should be handled in the future: the European Commission has recently published a communication setting the relevant policy trends. The present paper discusses some of these issues, proposing an analysis of what the concept means from the standpoint of materials stakeholders and how it can be refined or nuanced with a practical approach in mind. The core of the Circular Economy is the recycling of materials, which are recovered from the collection of end-of-life (EoL) investment or consumer goods. The key word is therefore recycling of EoL goods, materials, metals, minerals, residues and by-products and also molecules, like CO or CO2 (Carbon Capture Use and Storage, CCUS). Recycling brings materials savings and reduces the need for virgin resources (primary raw materials). When materials are recycled to the same material, other environmental benefits can also be collected, like energy savings, greenhouse gas emission reduction and a smaller environmental footprint in general. The kind of recycling that ought to be privileged is therefore that which improves all of these indicators at the same time, thus material-to-the-same material recycling. The circular economy should be described material by material, in order to analyze in detail what is already being done and what can still be improved: the various materials achieve very different levels of recycling and thus policies for going beyond present achievements will differ according to each material. The circular economy has an important time dimension, as many materials are stocked in the economy for long times, sometimes half a century or more. The lifespan of the material stocks means that high recycling rates today will be translated into high-recycled contents only in the future, sometimes in the long time. The Circular Economy is a long-time endeavor! There are two important tools for dealing with these issues, LCA (Life Cycle Assessment) and MFA (Materials Flow Analysis). They incorporate the cycle time of recycling but need to be expanded into dynamic LCA and MFA in order to become fully time-dependent. Policies founded on LCA at a microeconomic scale, and MFA at a macro-economic scale are the most apt to mirror how the socio-economic system works and thus to avoid negative rebound effects. Fostering the use of these tools is an important element in encouraging the Circular Economy. But it is also important to understand that the rationale for moving in this direction is environmental and political, not necessarily economical. Thus it will not be enough to foster technological R&D (Research & Development) and to achieve R&I (Research & Innovation): tools to internalize these externalities in the market economy will need to be introduced more widely.

Coupling material and energy flow analysis with life cycle assessment to support circular strategies at the urban level

Applying material and energy flow analysis to assess urban metabolism in the context of the circular economy

A review of material flow analysis

Integrating Strategic Environmental Assessment and Material Flow Accounting: a Novel Approach for Moving Towards Sustainable Urban Futures

An analysis of design strategies for circular economy through life cycle assessment

Evaluation of urban metabolism assessment methods through SWOT analysis and analytical hierocracy process

Enhanced Performance of the Eurostat Method for Comprehensive Assessment of Urban Metabolism: A Material Flow Analysis of Amsterdam

Circular life cycle sustainability assessment: An integrated framework

Hybridised sustainability metrics for use in life cycle assessment of bio-based products: resource efficiency and circularity

Cornell university campus metabolism and circular economy using a living laboratory approach to study major resource and material flows

Sustainable Agri-Food Processes and Circular Economy Pathways in a Life Cycle Perspective: State of the Art of Applicative Research

A Systematic Coupling Analysis Framework and Multi-Stage Interaction Mechanism Between Urban Land Use Efficiency and Ecological Carrying Capacity

Combining Building Information Model and Life Cycle Assessment for Defining Circular Economy Strategies

Combining the worlds of energy systems and material flow analysis: a review

Exploring the Missing Link between Life Cycle Assessment and Circularity Assessment in the Built Environment

Techniques and tools for integrating building material stock analysis and life cycle assessment at the urban scale: A systematic literature review

A critical review of material flow analysis (MFA)

Regional circular economy of building materials: Environmental and economic assessment combining Material Flow Analysis, Input‐Output Analyses, and Life Cycle Assessment

Life-cycle assessment, resource efficiency and recycling

Life cycle thinking and machine learning for urban metabolism assessment and prediction

Life Cycle Management Applied to Urban Fabric Planning