Human papillomavirus negative high grade cervical lesions and cancers: suggested guidance for hpv testing quality assurance
Jean Luc Prétet,Laila Sara Arroyo Mühr,Kate Cuschieri,María Dolores Fellner,Rita Mariel Correa,María Alejandra Picconi,Suzanne M. Garland,Gerald L. Murray,Monica Molano,Michael Peeters,Steven Van Gucht,Charlotte Lambrecht,Davy Vanden Broeck,Elizaveta Padalko,Marc Arbyn,Quentin Lepiller,Alice Brunier,Steffi Silling,Kristiane Søreng,Irene Kraus Christiansen,Mario Poljak,Camilla Lagheden,Emel Yilmaz,Carina Eklund,Hem R. Thapa,Troy D. Querec,Elizabeth R. Unger,Joakim Dillner
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcv.2024.105657
IF: 14.481
2024-02-22
Journal of Clinical Virology
Abstract:Background : Some high-grade cervical lesions and cervical cancers (HSIL+) test negative for human papillomavirus (HPV). The HPV-negative fraction varies between 0.03% and 15% between different laboratories. Monitoring and extended re-analysis of HPV-negative HSIL+ could thus be helpful to monitor performance of HPV testing services. We aimed to a) provide a real-life example of a quality assurance (QA) program based on re-analysis of HPV-negative HSIL+ and b) develop international guidance for QA of HPV testing services based on standardized identification of apparently HPV-negative HSIL+ and extended re-analysis, either by the primary laboratory or by a national HPV reference laboratory (NRL). Methods : There were 116 initially HPV-negative cervical specimens (31 histopathology specimens and 85 liquid-based cytology samples) sent to the Swedish HPV Reference Laboratory for re-testing. Based on the results, an international QA guidance was developed through an iterative consensus process. Result : Standard PCR testing detected HPV in 55.2% (64/116) of initially "HPV-negative" samples. Whole genome sequencing of PCR-negative samples identified HPV in an additional 7 samples (overall 61.2% HPV positivity). Reasons for failure to detect HPV in an HSIL+ lesion are listed and guidance to identify cases for extended re-testing, including which information should be included when referring samples to an NRL are presented. Conclusion : Monitoring the proportion of and reasons for failure to detect HPV in HSIL+ will help support high performance and quality improvement of HPV testing services. We encourage implementation of QA strategies based on re-analysis of "HPV negative" HSIL+ samples.
virology