The (probable) gas-rich nature of K2-18 b

Luca Maltagliati

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41550-024-02216-9

IF: 14.1

2024-02-22

Nature Astronomy

Abstract:The nature of exoplanet K2-18 b is under intense debate. A recent theory, purportedly supported by JWST data ( Astrophys. J. Lett. 956 , L13; 2023), suggested that this 2.6- R ⊕ planet in the classical 'habitable zone' of its star has a thin hydrogen-rich atmosphere but a water-rich interior and a global liquid water ocean — a 'Hycean' world — boosting its habitability prospects. Nicholas Wogan and colleagues temper these expectations by testing the feasibility of this scenario with coupled 1D photochemical and climate models. The authors simulate three states for K2-18 b: a lifeless Hycean world, an inhabited one with a simple biosphere that affects the atmospheric chemistry, and a gas-rich planet with a deep atmosphere akin to standard gas or icy giants. The results show that a lifeless Hycean world cannot explain the observed methane bands in the JWST spectra. Instead, the other two scenarios can fit the data with comparable goodness. Wogan et al. then compare the complexity of both possibilities and show that a cool habitable surface on K2-18 b would require very ad-hoc conditions to preserve a ~1-bar H 2 atmosphere from stellar radiation and avoid a runaway greenhouse effect at the same time. On the other hand, a standard 'mini-Neptune' can explain JWST observations straightforwardly.

astronomy & astrophysics