Generation and stability of bulk nanobubbles: A review and perspective

Limin Zhou,Shuo Wang,Lijuan Zhang,Jun Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cocis.2021.101439

2021-06-01

Abstract:<p>Bulk nanobubbles (BNBs) are submicron gaseous domains dispersed in solutions which are supposed to survive for several hours or even days. In recent years, there has been a rapid growth on the research and extraordinary applications of BNBs. However, conventional theories based on gas diffusion and Laplace pressure predicted that nanoscale gas bubbles in water should dissolve within microseconds, presenting a modern-day paradox in current nanobubbles researches. Also, it is still challenging to efficiently produce BNBs and determine their gaseous nature with the available techniques. In this review, we start from a general introduction and brief history of nanobubbles researches and revisit the current progress on the generation methods and detection techniques. Two possible formation mechanisms are suggested and the plausibility of the proposed theories on BNBs stability is discussed with some suggestions for future studies on bulk nanobubbles.</p>

chemistry, physical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are related to the generation and stability of bulk nanobubbles (BNBs). Specifically, the paper explores the following aspects:

1. **The stability paradox of nanobubbles**: According to the traditional gas diffusion theory and Laplace pressure theory, the lifespan of nanoscale bubbles in water should be very short, usually dissolving within the microsecond level. However, experimentally observed nanobubbles can exist stably for hours or even days, which contradicts the results predicted by traditional theories, forming a paradox in modern scientific research.

2. **Methods for efficiently generating bulk nanobubbles**: Currently, there are still certain challenges in the techniques and methods for generating bulk nanobubbles. The paper reviews the existing generation methods and discusses their advantages, disadvantages, and applicable ranges.

3. **Limitations of detection techniques**: Existing detection techniques have difficulties in distinguishing nanobubbles from other colloidal dispersion systems (such as solid nanoparticles, oil droplets, or biological vesicles). The paper explores currently commonly used detection techniques, such as light - scattering techniques and high - resolution electron microscopes, and points out their limitations.

4. **Theoretical explanations of the stabilization mechanism**: The paper proposes two possible formation mechanisms and discusses the rationality of these theories. At the same time, the paper also makes some suggestions for future research directions in order to better understand the stabilization mechanism of nanobubbles.

### Formula examples

- **Laplace equation**:
\[
\Delta P=\frac{2\gamma}{r}
\]
where \(\Delta P\) is the pressure difference between the inside and outside of the bubble, \(\gamma\) is the liquid surface tension, and \(r\) is the bubble radius.

- **Gibbs free energy change**:
\[
\Delta G = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^{3}\Delta G_{\text{lg}}+4\pi r^{2}\gamma
\]
where \(\Delta G\) is the Gibbs free energy change of forming a bubble nucleus, \(\Delta G_{\text{lg}}\) is the Gibbs free energy difference between the unit - volume liquid phase and gas phase, and \(\gamma\) is the surface tension of the gas - liquid interface.

Through these discussions, the paper aims to provide a theoretical basis and technical guidance for future research to further reveal the generation and stabilization mechanisms of nanobubbles.