"Head Up CPR" Is Not Ready for Widespread Adoption

Jeffrey L Jarvis,Michael R Sayre,Remle P Crowe,James J Menegazzi,Henry E Wang,Jeffrey L. Jarvis,Michael R. Sayre,Remle P. Crowe,James J. Menegazzi,Henry E. Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10903127.2024.2319697
2024-02-29
Prehospital Emergency Care
Abstract:Neuroprotective CPR (NPCPR) is a term coined for a bundle of care for patients in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) that features a mechanical chest compression device, impedance threshold device, and gradual delivery of head-up CPR (HUCPR) accomplished by an automated head and thorax elevation device. A recent position statement recommended "the widespread adoption of NPCPR as a best practice standard of care for all firefighters involved in first response to OHCA cases" ( Citation 1 , Citation 2 ). We disagree that either HUCPR or NPCPR are the standard of care and do not feel these practices should be widely adopted without additional, high-quality evidence. Additionally, we are concerned that use of the phrase "standard of care" is a legal term that carries potential liability for agencies not adhering to it. While the original position statement was subsequently rescinded, we believe it is important to highlight the limited evidence for HUCPR, describe the necessary steps for translating knowledge from the animal lab to the ambulance, and discuss implications for EMS practice ( Citation 3 ).
public, environmental & occupational health,emergency medicine
What problem does this paper attempt to address?