Zhao-Feng Yuan,Williamson Gustave,John Boyle,Raju Sekar,Jonathan Bridge,Yuxiang Ren,Xianjin Tang,Bin Guo,Zheng Chen
Abstract:The sharp redox gradient at soil-water interfaces (SWI) plays a key role in controlling arsenic (As) translocation and transformation in paddy soils. When Eh drops, As is released to porewater from solid iron (Fe) and manganese (Mn) minerals and reduced to arsenite. However, the coupling or decoupling processes operating within the redox gradient at the SWI in flooded paddy soils remain poorly constrained due to the lack of direct evidence. In this paper, we reported the mm-scale mapping of Fe, As and other associated elements across the redox gradient in the SWI of five different paddy soils. The results showed a strong positive linear relationship between dissolved Fe, Mn, As, and phosphorus (P) in 4 out of the 5 paddy soils, indicating the general coupling of these elements. However, decoupling of Fe, Mn and As was observed in one of the paddy soils. In this soil, distinct releasing profiles of Mn, As and Fe were observed, and the releasing order followed the redox ladder. Further investigation of As species showed the ratio of arsenite to total As dropped from 100% to 75.5% and then kept stable along depth of the soil profile, which indicates a dynamic equilibrium between arsenite oxidization and arsenate reduction. This study provides direct evidence of multi-elements' interaction along redox gradient of SWI in paddy soils.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to address the behavior of arsenic (As) at the soil - water interface (SWI) in paddy field soil, as well as its coupling and decoupling with elements such as iron (Fe) and manganese (Mn). Specifically, the study attempts to answer the following key questions:
1. **Arsenic Release Mechanism**: When paddy fields are flooded, the redox conditions in the soil change, causing arsenic to be released from solid - phase minerals into pore water. The study attempts to reveal the specific mechanism of this release process.
2. **Coupling and Decoupling between Elements**: The paper explores the coupling (i.e., whether the release and migration behaviors of these elements are consistent) or decoupling (i.e., whether the behaviors of these elements are independent) of arsenic, iron, manganese and other elements at the soil - water interface. For example, the coupling phenomenon of arsenic, iron and manganese has been observed in some soils, while their decoupling has been found in others.
3. **Arsenic Speciation Changes**: The study also focuses on the changes of different arsenic species (such as trivalent arsenic \( \text{As(III)} \) and pentavalent arsenic \( \text{As(V)} \)) at the soil - water interface. Especially under reducing conditions, the speciation changes of arsenic have an important impact on environmental risks.
4. **Multi - element Interactions**: By studying the distribution of different elements (such as phosphorus \( \text{P} \) and sulfur \( \text{S} \)) at the soil - water interface, their interactions and the impact on arsenic behavior are explored.
### Main Findings of the Paper
- **Coupling Phenomenon**: In four types of soils, there is a significant positive correlation among dissolved arsenic, iron and manganese, indicating that these elements usually show tight coupling in natural soils and sediments.
- **Decoupling Phenomenon**: The decoupling phenomenon of arsenic, iron and manganese has been observed in one type of soil. In particular, the release order of arsenic follows the redox gradient, and arsenide \( \text{As(III)} \) is released prior to arsenate \( \text{As(V)} \).
- **Arsenic Speciation Changes**: At the soil - water interface, arsenide \( \text{As(III)} \) is released earlier than arsenate \( \text{As(V)} \), indicating that the release of arsenide occurs preferentially under reducing conditions.
- **Dynamic Equilibrium**: In deep - layer soils, the ratio of arsenide to arsenate remains stable, indicating the existence of a dynamic equilibrium, that is, a balance has been reached between the oxidation of arsenide and the reduction of arsenate, as well as their fixation and release.
Through these studies, the paper provides direct evidence for understanding the behavior of arsenic in paddy field soil, and is helpful for predicting and mitigating its accumulation in crops, thereby ensuring food safety and human health.