Abstract:Background The dissemination of rumor rebuttal content on social media is vital for rumor control and disease containment during public health crises. Previous research on the effectiveness of rumor rebuttal, to a certain extent, ignored or simplified the structure of dissemination networks and users’ cognition as well as decision-making and interaction behaviors. Objective This study aimed to roughly evaluate the effectiveness of rumor rebuttal; dig deeply into the attitude-based echo chamber effect on users’ responses to rumor rebuttal under multiple topics on Weibo, a Chinese social media platform, in the early stage of the COVID-19 epidemic; and evaluate the echo chamber’s impact on the information characteristics of user interaction content. Methods We used Sina Weibo’s application programming interface to crawl rumor rebuttal content related to COVID-19 from 10 AM on January 23, 2020, to midnight on April 8, 2020. Using content analysis, sentiment analysis, social network analysis, and statistical analysis, we first analyzed whether and to what extent there was an echo chamber effect on the shaping of individuals’ attitudes when retweeting or commenting on others’ tweets. Then, we tested the heterogeneity of attitude distribution within communities and the homophily of interactions between communities. Based on the results at user and community levels, we made comprehensive judgments. Finally, we examined users’ interaction content from three dimensions—sentiment expression, information seeking and sharing, and civility—to test the impact of the echo chamber effect. Results Our results indicated that the retweeting mechanism played an essential role in promoting polarization, and the commenting mechanism played a role in consensus building. Our results showed that there might not be a significant echo chamber effect on community interactions and verified that, compared to like-minded interactions, cross-cutting interactions contained significantly more negative sentiment, information seeking and sharing, and incivility. We found that online users’ information-seeking behavior was accompanied by incivility, and information-sharing behavior was accompanied by more negative sentiment, which was often accompanied by incivility. Conclusions Our findings revealed the existence and degree of an echo chamber effect from multiple dimensions, such as topic, interaction mechanism, and interaction level, and its impact on interaction content. Based on these findings, we provide several suggestions for preventing or alleviating group polarization to achieve better rumor rebuttal.

Cognitive disparity in online rumor perception: a group analysis during COVID-19

Exploring rumor behavior during the COVID-19 pandemic through an information processing perspective: The moderating role of critical thinking

Online rumors during the COVID-19 pandemic: co-evolution of themes and emotions

Internet Rumors During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Dynamics of Topics and Public Psychologies

Dynamics of changes in the psychosocial characteristics of online media consumers under the influence of official information and rumors about COVID-19

Factors affecting individual online rumor sharing behavior in the COVID-19 pandemic

Factors influencing college students' online rumor refuting behavior during major public health crises: the moderating effect of group norms

“I Heard That COVID-19 Was...”: Rumors, Pandemic, and Psychological Distance

The "parallel Pandemic" in the Context of China: the Spread of Rumors and Rumor-Corrections During COVID-19 in Chinese Social Media.

The echo chamber effect of rumor rebuttal behavior of users in the early stage of COVID-19 epidemic in China

Understanding the role of social media usage and health self-efficacy in the processing of COVID-19 rumors: A SOR perspective

The Effect of Group Arguments on Commercial Rumor Spreading in Chinese Online Discussion Forum: a Conformity and Polarization Perspective

Know it to Defeat it: Exploring Health Rumor Characteristics and Debunking Efforts on Chinese Social Media during COVID-19 Crisis

A Study on the Effectiveness of Rumor Control via Social Media Networks to Alleviate Public Panic About COVID-19

Quantitative Analysis on the Communication of COVID-19 Related Social Media Rumors

Effects of group arguments on rumor belief and transmission in online communities: An information cascade and group polarization perspective.

Fake news in a time of plague: Exploring individuals' online information management in the COVID-19 era

What Breeds Conspiracy Theories in COVID-19? The Role of Risk Perception in the Belief in COVID-19 Conspiracy

Echo Chamber Effect in Rumor Rebuttal Discussions About COVID-19 in China: Social Media Content and Network Analysis Study

Community Notes vs. Related Articles: Assessing Real-World Integrated Counter-Rumor Features in Response to Different Rumor Types on Social Media