Substituting Book Reading for Screen Time Benefits Preschoolers' Sleep Health: Results from the Ulm SPATZ Health Study
Cristian Ricci,Madeleine Ordnung,Dietrich Rothenbacher,Jon Genuneit
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/nss.s448736
2024-03-20
Nature and Science of Sleep
Abstract:Cristian Ricci, 1, 2 Madeleine Ordnung, 1 Dietrich Rothenbacher, 3 Jon Genuneit 1, 3 1 Pediatric Epidemiology, Department of Pediatrics, Medical Faculty, Leipzig University, Leipzig, Germany; 2 Africa Unit for Transdisciplinary Health Research (AUTHeR), North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa; 3 Institute of Epidemiology and Medical Biometry, Ulm University, Ulm, Germany Correspondence: Madeleine Ordnung, Liebigstraße 20a, Haus 6, Leipzig, 04103, Germany, Tel +49 341 - 97 24182, Fax +49 341 - 97 28210, Email Purpose: Healthy sleep is essential for the physical, cognitive, and social development of children. Several studies have reported the increase in digital media use in preschool children and its association with impaired sleep. However, there is relatively little evidence on the effects of book reading as a potentially safe alternative. The objective of this study, therefore, was to investigate whether sleep in children could benefit from book reading, and whether the negative effects of media use on sleep can be mitigated by substituting book reading for screen time. Participants and Methods: We used longitudinal data from three consecutive waves of the SPATZ Health study, including children at the ages of 4 (n=581), 5 (n=508), and 6 (n=426) years. All data were collected by self-administered questionnaires. Parent-reported child sleep was assessed by the Children's Sleep Habits Questionnaire. Results: Across the three waves, screen-based media use increased and was associated with lower sleep quality. In contrast, the time spent with book reading decreased; however, book reading appeared to be beneficial for children's sleep. Substitution models revealed that the theoretical substitution of an equal amount of book reading for 50% of the time spent with screen-based media benefits several domains of preschoolers' sleep health, including parasomnias, sleep anxiety, daytime sleepiness, and sleep onset delay. Conclusion: Besides implications for population-wide and individual prevention, book reading may also be incorporated as a useful intervention to improve sleep quality in children who are already affected by sleep problems. Given that book reading is perceived as a safe alternative, the presented evidence may suffice to support recommendations in this direction. Keywords: digital media, paper book, sleep health, sleep quality, children, preschoolers Healthy sleep is crucial for mental and physical health and well-being at all ages, including childhood. 1,2 Unfortunately, sleep problems are well documented in children, affecting 15–50% of children. 3–5 In European children, the prevalence of sleep problems seems comparable to that observed in the USA and China. 6–8 This has resulted in several calls to act now and early in life, eg by promoting sleep health, including regular sleep assessment, in primary care, similarly to other vital signs, and by encouraging the use of wearable devices and mobile applications to evaluate and monitor sleep behavior. 5 Children's sleep health is influenced by many factors, including bedtime being determined by parents, early school starting times, 9,10 feeding practices, 11 and family socioeconomic status. 12,13 Among the modifiable factors, media use continues to spike interest, 14,15 probably owing to its inevitable presence in our modern societies or its wide-ranging potential benefits and negative consequences. 16 Here, screen-based media (eg TV, tablet, smartphone, e-book) need to be distinguished from paper book reading, since there seem to be antagonistic effects regarding sleep behavior in children. 17–19 For instance, whereas sleep (eg sleep onset, subjective sleepiness, sleep duration) has shown to be impaired in children watching TV or reading an e-book before bedtime, reading a paper book appeared to be beneficial. In general, there is relatively little evidence about the effects of book reading on sleep health; 20 on the other hand, associations between screen-based media and sleep problems in children are widely reported. 21 Suggested explanations for these associations include 1) displacement of sleep with media use, 22,23 although some work shows a mere shift of sleep phase rather than shorter sleep duration, 24 and displacement of daytime sleep in preschoolers may induce more consolidated night-time sleep; 25 2) melatonin suppression by blue light emission from screens; 26 and 3) arousal linked to content, 27 to lack of parental involvement in the activity, 28 or to dysfunctional bedtime r -Abstract Truncated-
neurosciences,clinical neurology