Abstract:This paper examines the morning commute problem when both household commuters and individual commuters are considered in a Y-shaped network with two upstream links and a single downstream link. The household parents daily pass through an upstream bottleneck with a limited capacity before a school and drop off their children. Then, they traverse the downstream bottleneck common to both household and individual commuters and arrive at the workplace. We explore the effects of staggering policy, that is, staggering work and school start times, on the distribution of traffic congestion and social welfare. We analytically solve all the equilibrium cases and reveal all the traffic congestion patterns. The results reveal that the staggering policy may be harmful in certain cases. When the demand of individuals is relatively low, the staggering policy may not improve social welfare. When the demand of individuals is high, social welfare can be significantly improved if the schedule gap between the work start time and school start time is optimized. The effects of the staggering policy on system performance are examined. We derive a Pareto frontier, which provides a good candidate set for policymakers when the two system performance measures, that is, the total system cost and the total congestion cost, are considered. Our results show that the optimal staggering policy on system performance depends on the demand distribution of the two groups. When the demand of individuals is high, there exists a unique optimal staggering policy that optimizes system performance. However, when the demand of individuals is low, the optimal staggering policy should be selected from the Pareto frontier. Furthermore, we re-examine the capacity expansion paradox under the staggering policy. Our study shows the capacity expansion at the downstream bottleneck can always reduce the total system cost. However, the paradoxical phenomenon may arise when the capacity of the upstream bottleneck is expanded, but it can be eliminated if the schedule gap is properly designed.

Experimental study and modeling of departure time choice behavior in the bottleneck model with staggered work hours

Agent-Based Microsimulation Approach for Design and Evaluation of Flexible Work Schedules

Modeling Morning Commute Problem with Real-Time Ridesharing Services

Modeling the Peak-Period Bus Commuting Behavior with Staggered Work Hours Using a Regret-Minimizing Learning Method

Bottleneck Congestion And Work Starting Time Distribution Considering Household Travels

A Dynamic Day-To-Day Departure Time and Route Choice Model for Bounded-Rational Individuals

The Analysis of Dynamic Travel Mode Choice: A Heterogeneous Hidden Markov Approach

Departure Time and Route Choice Model Based on Travel Profit

Modeling Departure Time Choice under Stochastic Networks Involved in Network Design

On the Morning Commute Problem in a Y-shaped Network with Individual and Household Travelers

Stable day-to-day dynamics for departure time choice

Day-to-day Traffic Flow Assignment Model Considering Departure Time Adjustment

An Agent-Based Choice Model for Travel Mode and Departure Time and Its Case Study in Beijing

A Paradox of Telecommuting and Staggered Work Hours in the Bottleneck Model

Day-to-day evolution of departure time choice in stochastic capacity bottleneck models with bounded rationality and various information perceptions

Boundedly Rational Departure Time Choice in a Dynamic Continuum User Equilibrium Model for an Urban City

The Issue of Subway Commuters' Departure Time Choices under the Influence of Bike‐Sharing

Departure time choices and a modeling framework for a guidance system

Research on the multiroute probit-based public transit assignment model based on bus stop

Multiday User Equilibrium with Strategic Commuters

A Data-Driven and Optimal Bus Scheduling Model with Time-Dependent Traffic and Demand