Difficult lives explain depression better than broken brains

Joanna Moncrieff,Ruth E. Cooper,Tom Stockmann,Simone Amendola,Michael P. Hengartner,Mark A. Horowitz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41380-024-02462-3
IF: 11
2024-02-20
Molecular Psychiatry
Abstract:Human beings are organisms with brains who have emotions and agency. The nature and size of our brains is what gives us these capacities, but our feelings and our behaviour are not best understood as simply the property of our brains. They are the properties of us as whole human beings immersed in our social world [1]. Inappropriately ascribing feelings, thoughts, preferences and other characteristics of humans to the brain is known as the mereological fallacy [2]. For example, the association between activation of certain areas of the brain and 'liking the Beatles' could be studied, but this preference is more likely to be understood by examining the relationships and experiences associated with this music in the person's life. The same applies to feelings of despair and hopelessness. First it is worth stating that none of the four correspondents [3,4,5,6] challenge the conclusion of our umbrella review [7] which was that we found 'no support for the hypothesis that depression is caused by lowered serotonin activity or concentrations.'
biochemistry & molecular biology,neurosciences,psychiatry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?