Aetiology of Hodgkin's Disease with Special Reference to B. Tuberculosis Avis
C. van Rooyen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.1.3758.50
1933-01-14
British Medical Journal
Abstract:The relation of Hodgkin's disease to tuberculosis has been the subject of extensive inquiry, and many workers, such as Sternberg (1898), Ewing (1927), and others, have repeafedly drawn attention to the similarity of tissue changes produced in both conditions. Opinion, however, is divided on the incidence of tuberculosis in patients suffering from lymphadenoma. Ewing says that " tuberculosis follows Hodgkin's disease like a shadow "; Lemon (1924) reports, to the contrary, that out of 191 cases of Hodgkin's disease under observation in the Mayo Clinic only eight showed evidence of tuberculosis. The latter worker further states that out of twenty-six cases of the disease in which the mediastinal glands were involved there was definite evidence of tuberculosis in only one. Infective agents other than the tubercle bacillus, such as the diphtheroid organism (Bunting and Yates, 1913), certain moniliae (Dias, 1918) and amoebae (Kofoid, Swezy, and Boyers, 1922), have been described in Hodgkin's disease, but such work has lacked confirmation. Stewart and Dobson (1924) attempted to reproduce the disease in monkeys (rhesus and bonnet), but without results. Twort in 1930 published the results of six years' research into the causation of the condition, and arrived at the conclusion that the disease was probably of neoplastic origin, since he was unable to isolate any one organism with constancy or to reproduce the disease in laboratory animals with pathological material. More recently American workers have advanced two fresh views on the aetiology of the condition. Medlar (1931) maintains that the disease is one primarily affecting the bone marrow, for which he proposes the name " megakaryoblastoma " in view of the particular type of cell involved. L'Esperance (1929-31) claims to have reproduced Hodgkin's disease in birds and " treated " guinea-pigs, from whose tissues she recovered the avian tubercle bacillus. This investigator therefore states that Hodgkin's disease is produced by infection with B. tuberculosis avis. This view has bern further elaborated by Utz and Keatinge (1932), who claim to have treated successfully several cases of lymphadenoma by the use of serums obtained from chickens previously immunized with lymphadenomatous tissue. I have investigated the claims of L'Esperance by the inoculation of chickens and other laboratory animals with material obtained at biopsy from three cases clinically and histologically characteristic of Hodgkin's disease, and also with material removed at necropsy from three other cases of the disease, two of which showed mediastinal involvement. The following brief extracts of case and post-mortem notes describe the subjects from which material was obtained. CASE HISTORIES 1. Case of Professor Fraser's.-A male, aged 52, had swelling in left axilla of eleven months' duration, with later ulceration and secondary infection lasting three months. There was slight enlargement of the inguinal and infraclavicular glands, with no evidence of mediastinal involvement. Ten per cent. eosinophils were present. Histological diagnosis: Hodgkin's disease. 2. Case of Dr. Conzrie's.-A female, aged 28, had a swelling of the glands of the neck for eight months, with later involvement of abdominal glands and spleen. These changes were accompanied by extensive bronzing of the skin and intolerable itching. Throughout her illness a fever conforming to the Pel-Ebstein type was present, and the blood picture showed an eosinophilia. At post-mortem the cervical, mediastinal, bronchial, and abdominal para-aortic glands were grossly enlarged, together with slight enlargement of the lymph nodes of the lesser omentum. The spleen was enlarged to about three times its normal size, and contained numerous nodules throughout. The heart, liver, and lungs also showed inivolvement with lymphadenomatous tissue. 3. Case of Professor D. Murray Lyon's.-A male, aged 46, complained of vague symptoms of general illness lasting three months, with loss of appetite and weight, diarrhoea, colic, and dyspnoea. Temperature reaction of the Pel-Ebstein type was present, accompanied by enlargement of liver and spleen. At post-mortem there was considerable enlargement of paraaortic, abdominal, and mediastinal lymph glands, with commencing enlargement of the cervical and inguinal groups. The bone marrow revealed red patches suggestive of erythroblastic reaction, and microscopically proliferation of bone marrow cells affecting the red cell series was found to be present. 4. Case of Professor Bramwell's.-A male, aged 27, gave a three months' history of loss of weight and appetite, accompanied by distension of the abdomen and bronzing of the skin. On admission the patient was found to have an enlarged spleen, dullness over the apex of the right lobe, with crepitations and vesicular breathing. Pel-Ebstein type of fever was present. Red blood cells were 4,200,000 per c.mm., and white cells 3,800: differential count was normal, and haemoglobin 70 ser cent. Post-mortem revealed typical lymphadenoma of spleen, liver, and para-aortic and cervical glands. Brown atrophy of the heart. No evidence of tuberculosis demonstrable. 5. Case of Professor Fraser's.-A female, aged 31, first noticed lumps on her neck two years before examination, initially confined to the left side, but lafer involving the right. These painless swellings rapidly increased in size, and later gave rise to pressure symptoms in that region. There was no palpable enlargement of spleen, liver, or lymph glands in inguinal or axillary regions. An intermittent fever accompanied her illness. Red blood cells were 4,540,000 per c.mm., and white cells 9,200: polymorphs, 75 per cent. ; lymphocytes, small, 11 per cent.; large, 9 per cent.; eosinophils, 4 per cent.; transitionals 1 per cent. Haemoglobin was 70 per cent. ; colour index, 0.08. Histological diagnosis: Hodgkin's disease. Deep x-ray therapy and subcutaneous injections of Coley's fluid over the affected area were employed, which resulted in marked diminution in the size of the glands and considerable general improvement. 6. Case of Dr. Chalmers Watson's.-A schoolboy, aged 8, gave a five years' history of progressive enlargement of submental, supraclavicular, axillary, and inguinal glands, and of the spleen. Increasing weakness and cachexia, severe secondary anaemia, accompanied by cardiac haemic murmurs, commencing integumentary dryness and pigmentation were present. During the last two years patient exhibited a typical PelEbstein pyrexia. The histological diagnosis, clinical manifestations, course of the disease, and reaction to deep x-ray therapy have shown this case to be almost a textbook picture of the disease.