Abstract:Introduction: Although attending substance use-focused mutual-help meetings online may reduce attendance barriers, associations of attendance mode with group participation and outcomes are unknown. Using longitudinal data from mutual-help group attendees, this study, after identifying differences in baseline characteristics by attendance mode, examined associations of attendance mode with mutual-help participation (number of meetings attended, involvement) and outcomes (alcohol abstinence, heavy drinking, alcohol problems). Methods: The Peer Alternatives for Addiction Study 2021 Cohort sampled attendees of 12-step groups (e.g., Alcoholics Anonymous), Women for Sobriety, LifeRing Secular Recovery, and/or SMART Recovery in-person and/or online within 30 days before baseline. The baseline sample, recruited in fall 2021, was 531 adults with lifetime alcohol use disorder, followed at 6 (88 %) and 12 months (85 %). Differences in baseline characteristics by attendance mode were tested using Chi-squares and ANOVAs. GEE models examined associations of attendance mode, time, and their interactions with mutual-help group participation and alcohol outcomes. The in-person only mode was compared to the online-only, and to the in-person plus online, modes. Results: At baseline, 53.7 % of participants had attended only online meetings in the past 30 days, 33.7 % had attended both in-person and online meetings, and 12.6 % had attended only in-person meetings. Online meeting attendees were less likely to endorse lifetime abstinence as an alcohol recovery goal than in-person-only meeting attendees. In adjusted models (including for recovery goal), those attending online meetings only, or both online and in-person meetings, attended a greater number of meetings compared to those attending only in-person meetings. However, online-only attendance was associated with less involvement than in-person-only attendance. In adjusted models, compared to baseline, involvement increased and outcomes improved at follow-ups. Adjusted models examining alcohol outcomes found that no attendance at mutual-help groups at follow-ups was associated with more heavy drinking compared to in-person-only attendance. Conclusions: Findings inform efforts to ascertain benefits of mutual-help group participation by suggesting that online attendance is associated with attending more meetings, less involvement, and lower endorsement of abstinence as a recovery goal, and is comparable to in-person attendance on alcohol outcomes. In-person attendance may be more beneficial for less heavy drinking than terminating attendance.

Using conventional and machine learning propensity score methods to examine the effectiveness of 12-step group involvement following inpatient addiction treatment

Using Propensity Scores to Adjust for Selection Bias when Assessing the Effectiveness of Alcoholics Anonymous in Observational Studies.

Self-help groups and opioid use disorder treatment: An investigation using a machine learning-assisted robust causal inference framework

Alcohol and Drug Treatment Involvement, 12-Step Attendance and Abstinence: 9-Year Cross-Lagged Analysis of Adults in an Integrated Health Plan.

Predicting post-treatment-initiation alcohol use among patients with severe mental illness and alcohol use disorders.

Time-lagged association between counseling and/or 12-Step attendance with subsequent opioid use in a secondary analysis from a randomized, clinical trial of medications for opioid use disorder

Levels and outcomes of 12-step participation among sexual and gender minority subgroups

Prevalence and correlates of 12‐step and second‐wave mutual‐help attendance in a nationally representative US sample

The effectiveness of post-discharge navigation added to an inpatient addiction consultation for patients with substance use disorder; a randomized controlled trial

Understanding the Factors that Impact Relapse Post-residential Addiction Treatment, a Six Month Follow-up from a Canadian Treatment Centre

The Twelve Promises of Alcoholics Anonymous: psychometric measure validation and mediational testing as a 12-step specific mechanism of behavior change

Mode of mutual-help group attendance: Predictors and outcomes in a US national longitudinal survey of adults with lifetime alcohol use disorder

Longitudinal predictors of 12-step attendance among substance-abusing women

Predicting longitudinal service use for individuals with substance use disorders: A latent profile analysis

Effectiveness of Residential Treatment Services for Veterans with Substance Use Disorders: A Propensity Score Matching Evaluation

Sign-tracking to non-drug reward is related to severity of alcohol-use problems in a sample of individuals seeking treatment

The effect of significant other involvement in treatment for substance use disorders: A meta-analysis.

Associations between mental health & substance use treatment and alcohol use progression and recovery among US women drinkers

Results from a Randomized Clinical Study on Inpatient Peer Recovery Coaching

Craving for a Robust Methodology: A Systematic Review of Machine Learning Algorithms on Substance-Use Disorders Treatment Outcomes

Factors Associated with Mental Health Clinicians' Referrals to 12-Step Groups