Silencing is the Real Crime: Youth and Elders Talk About Climate

Sally Weintrobe
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00797308.2023.2287380
2024-01-26
The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child
Abstract:Climate conversations held in the UK with youth, with elders, and then with the youth and elders together (an intergenerational group) are analyzed. Youth were consciously aware of, knew about, were very emotionally troubled by, and were taking action on the climate emergency. Elders were less informed, wavered between and within themselves between disavowal and awareness of climate impacts. Difficulties with managing guilt featured in both age groups, with the youth showing more depressive reparative guilt and the elders more paranoid-schizoid, avoidant, and blaming guilt, which made it difficult for them to listen to and support the youth in the first intergenerational group. Elders were more supportive in the second meeting with youth. Some seemed shocked at their initial lack of interest, empathy, and support and by realizing how grim the youth were at times feeling. The youth conversations, explored in detail, reveal remarkable resilience in staying mindful when faced both with climate reality and with being silenced by a culture of uncare. Youth are aware that climate reality (both physical and social) affects their mental health. Main conclusions are it is vital to talk about climate, but also vital not to underestimate the emotional effects of being silenced when we do speak up; that climate reality can at times be too much for mind to bear, and a supportive group is needed to help to bear it: the issue is preserving the very capacity to think.
psychology, psychoanalysis
What problem does this paper attempt to address?