Abstract:In their recent article, Nfor et al. [Optik - International Journal for Light and Electron Optics 285 (2023) 170951, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijleo.2023.170951] have studied, through a dissipative nonlinear Schrödinger equation, the modulational instability and soliton trains in optical fiber media with real and imaginary Raman gains. After finding a steady-state solution of this equation, they have applied the linear stability analysis to investigate its modulational instability. It appears that (i) their proposed steady-state solution is not really a continuous wave solution of their model equation, and (ii) their ansatz used for the modulation perturbation function violate all mathematical/physical rules, leading thus to an inappropriate results. Moreover, during their development on exact analytical solutions, authors have not established conditions under which those analytical solutions may exist, as one can easily verify in subsection 3.1. It is the aim of the present comment to correct all shortcomings about the modulational instability study carried out in their study. We start by presenting the correct steady-state solution of the considered dissipative nonlinear Schrödinger equation, and then investigate with details its modulational instability. We end this comment by establishing conditions under which equation (15) admits analytical solutions of form (16) when a6=0 , and the present some other interesting solutions of this equation (16).

Comment on “Weierstrass and Jacobi elliptic, bell and kink type, lumps, Ma and Kuznetsov breathers with rogue wave solutions to the dissipative nonlinear Schrödinger equation”

Comment on "Optical solitons for 2D-NLSE in multimode fiber with Kerr nonlinearity and its modulation instability"

A comment about the paper On the instability of elliptic traveling wave solutions of the modified Camassa-Holm equation

Comment on “Bilinear Bäcklund transformation, soliton and periodic wave solutions for a (3+1)-dimensional variable-coefficient generalized shallow water wave equation” (Nonlinear Dyn. 87, 2529, 2017)

Comment on the paper of El-Ganaini et al. [Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 140 (2020) 110218]

Comment on "Modulational instability and soliton trains in optical fiber media with real and imaginary Raman gains"

Breather Solutions to a Two-dimensional Nonlinear Schrödinger Equation with Non-local Derivatives

Comments on the paper "Derivation of lump solutions to a variety of Boussinesq equations with distinct dimensions."

On an intercritical log-modified nonlinear Schrodinger equation in two spatial dimensions

Multi-breathers and high order rogue waves for the nonlinear Schrödinger equation on the elliptic function background

The Rogue Wave of the Nonlinear Schrödinger Equation with Self-Consistent Sources

New rational and breather solutions of a higher-order integrable nonlinear Schrödinger equation

Letter to the Editor on a shallow water wave equation in Results Phys. 43, 106048 (2022) and its generalization

Linear Instability of Breathers for the Focusing Nonlinear Schrödinger Equation

New derivation of the amplitude of asymptotic oscillatory tails of weakly delocalized solitons

Breathers, Rogue Waves and Their Dynamics in a (2+1)-Dimensional Nonlinear Schrödinger Equation

Numerical Analysis of the Hirota Equation: Modulational Instability, Breathers, Rogue Waves, and Interactions.

High-order rogue waves and their dynamics of the Fokas–Lenells equation revisited: a variable separation technique

Breathing-soliton and singular rogue wave solutions for a discrete nonlocal coupled Ablowitz–Ladik equation of reverse-space type

Asymptotic behavior for a class of logarithmic wave equations with Balakrishnan-Taylor damping, nonlinear weak damping and strong linear damping

Multi-breather and high-order rogue waves for the quintic nonlinear Schrödinger equation on the elliptic function background