Abstract:Understanding the determinants of biodiversity in fragmented habitats is fundamental for informing sustainable landscape development, especially in urban landscapes that substantially fragment natural habitat. However, the relative roles of landscape and habitat characteristics, as emphasized by two competing frameworks (the island biogeography theory and the habitat diversity hypothesis), in structuring species assemblages in fragmented habitats have not been fully explored. This study investigated bird assemblages at 26 habitat patches (ranging in size from 0.3 to 290.4 ha) in an urban landscape, southwest China, among which habitat type composition and woody plant species composition varied significantly. Through 14 bird surveys conducted over six breeding seasons from 2017 to 2022, we recorded 70 breeding bird species (excluding birds recorded only once and fly-overs, such as raptors, swallows and swifts), with an average of 26 ± 10 (SD) species per patch. We found that patch area had significant direct and indirect effects on bird richness, with the indirect effects mediated by habitat richness (i.e., the number of habitat types). Isolation (measured as the distance to the nearest patch), perimeter to area ratio (PAR), and woody plant richness did not significantly predict variation in bird richness. Furthermore, none of these factors significantly sorted bird species based on their functional traits. However, the overall makeup of bird assemblages was significantly associated with the specific habitat types and woody plant species present in the patches. The results suggest that neither the island biogeography theory nor the habitat diversity hypothesis can fully explain the impacts of habitat fragmentation on bird richness in our study system, with their roles primarily being linked to patch area. The findings that habitat and plant compositions were the major drivers of variation in bird assemblage composition offer valuable insights into urban planning and green initiatives. Conservation efforts should focus not only on preserving large areas, but also on preventing urban monocultures by promoting diverse habitats within those areas, contributing to the persistence of meta-communities.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores how landscape and habitat characteristics influence the structure of bird communities in urban habitat patches. Specifically, the study aims to address the following key questions: 1. **Applicability of Theoretical Frameworks**: The study attempts to evaluate the effectiveness of the island biogeography theory and the habitat diversity hypothesis in explaining variations in bird species richness within urban habitat patches. These two theories respectively emphasize the different roles of area reduction and habitat diversity. 2. **Impact of Habitat Patch Characteristics**: It investigates the specific effects of habitat patch size (area), degree of isolation, edge effects (represented by the perimeter-to-area ratio), and the richness of habitats and woody plants on bird species richness. 3. **Relationship Between Functional Traits and Habitat**: It examines whether these characteristics of habitat patches filter bird species according to specific functional traits (such as body size, flight efficiency, etc.). 4. **Impact of Habitat Composition on Bird Community Composition**: It analyzes the overall impact of different habitat types (including woodland, shrubland, grassland, wetland, exposed karst rocks, and farmland) and the composition of woody plant species on bird community composition. The study results indicate: - The area of habitat patches has a significant direct impact on bird species richness, and this effect is further enhanced through the mediating factor of habitat richness. - The degree of isolation, perimeter-to-area ratio, and woody plant richness did not significantly predict changes in bird species richness. - Specific habitat types and the composition of woody plant species in habitat patches are closely related to bird community composition. - Functional trait analysis shows that these characteristics of habitat patches do not significantly filter bird species based on their functional traits. In summary, the study points out that neither the island biogeography theory nor the habitat diversity hypothesis alone can strongly explain the impact of habitat fragmentation on bird species richness in the study system. Instead, habitat type and plant composition are the main factors driving variations in bird community composition. This provides valuable insights for urban planning and green initiatives, emphasizing the need to protect large habitat areas while also maintaining and promoting habitat diversity to support the persistence of metacommunities.

Quantifying the effects of landscape and habitat characteristics on structuring bird assemblages in urban habitat patches