Abstract:The survivability of the domestic nuclear power industry depends on the cost-competitiveness of safe and secure nuclear power generation. Advanced reactor design concepts aim to have increased safety margins over traditional large light water reactors (LWRs). With increased safety margins comes the potential for a corresponding decrease in off-site risk to the general public from a hypothetical release of radioactivity due to sabotage or theft. Without sacrificing safety or security, advanced reactor designers may be able to achieve operational cost improvements over current LWRs in part by designing less burdensome physical protection systems (PPSs) and by replacing on-site response forces with off-site response forces. To accommodate these developments, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission is drafting new rulemakings for physical security when licensing through the current frameworks in 10 CFR 50 or 10 CFR 52 along with drafting an entirely new licensing framework: 10 CFR 53. A novel technology-inclusive consequence-informed methodology for the selection of the optimal licensing path for the design of PPSs at advanced fixed-site commercial nuclear power facilities is presented herein. This methodology proposes integrating security considerations at the beginning of a reactor facility design effort to streamline the licensing process. Off-site total effective dose equivalents at the exclusion area and low population zone boundaries were identified as the key metrics when determining a design's most appropriate licensing path that in turn affects the design requirements placed upon the PPS. Given these metrics, source-term generation of potential adversary-induced physics-based sabotage actions utilizing severe accident modeling software and off-site plume dispersal modeling were identified as appropriate for determining siting constraints, potential target sets for hypothetical sabotage events, and their subsequent off-site dose consequences. The methodology proposes using the consequence results from the sabotage modeling, in combination with desired cost-saving PPS characteristics, to help inform the licensing path selection. Once a licensing path is chosen, the methodology utilizes the Design and Evaluation Process Outline to evaluate an effective PPS following the licensing requirements placed on the facility. This paper also presents examples of hypothetical commercial nuclear power facilities with varying consequence levels and demonstrations of how to select the optimal licensing pathways for each.

Development of a Potential Facility Risk Index for Nuclear Safety and Security Using a Terrorism Scenario with a Hypothetical Nuclear Facility

Integrated Safety and Security Analysis of Nuclear Power Plants Using Dynamic Event Trees

A Consequence-Informed Licensing Path Selection for the Design of Physical Protection Systems at Commercial Nuclear Power Facilities

Risk Analysis and Evaluation of Nuclear Security Radiation Events in Spent Fuel Reprocessing Plants

A dynamic probabilistic risk assessment platform for nuclear power plants under single and concurrent transients

Multi-unit PSA Based Risk Evaluation Framework for Utilizing Cross-Tie Systems for Nuclear Power Plants

Quantification of risk dilution induced by correlation parameters in dynamic probabilistic risk assessment of nuclear power plants

Safety scenario and integrated thermofluid test

Research on Radiation Monitoring Strategy for Spent Fuel Reprocessing Plant Based on Coordination of Nuclear Security Risk and Facility Importance Evaluation

A Demonstration of the Risk-Informed NEI 18-04 Design Evaluation Model for the Modular High-Temperature Gas Reactor

Recommendations for Conducting Probabilistic Risk Assessment of Spent Fuel Storage Facilities

Exploring the limits of safety analysis in complex technological systems

An IT2FS-ANP- and IT2FS-CM-Based Approach for Conducting Safety Risk Assessments of Nuclear Power Plant Building Projects

Accident Sequence Precursor Analysis of an Incident in a Japanese Nuclear Power Plant Based on Dynamic Probabilistic Risk Assessment

Quantifying Safety Significance: An In-Depth Analysis of Importance Measures in Level 1 PSA for the VVR 10-MW Water-Water Research Reactor

Simulation-based dynamic probabilistic risk assessment of an internal flooding-initiated accident in nuclear power plant using THALES2 and RAPID

Probabilistic Risk Assessment Framework Development for Nuclear Power Plant

External Event Risk Assessment: Methodology and Application

Preliminary risk assessment of in-vessel leakage accident in ITER

Some Issues of Assessing the Risk Potential of Technological Process at Nuclear Power Plants

Evaluation of the unavailability of the primary circuit of Triga SSR reactor, importance factors and risk criteria for its components