Analysis of Small-Signal Power Oscillations in MTDC Power Transmission System

Qiang Fu,Wenjuan Du,H. F. Wang,Bixing Ren

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tpwrs.2020.3043041

IF: 7.326

2021-07-01

IEEE Transactions on Power Systems

Abstract:This paper investigates the small-signal power oscillations in a VSC-based multi-terminal DC (MTDC) power transmission system. Regarding the DC power oscillation modes (DPOMs), this paper demonstrates that when the master–slave control is adopted for the MTDC power system, there is only one DPOM. In contrast, when the DC voltage droop control is adopted, the DC electric power oscillations (DEPOs) may be multi-modal oscillations as there are multiple DPOMs. Furthermore, a better understanding of DEPOs, which is analogous to low-frequency electric power oscillations (LEPOs) in conventional AC power systems, is obtained, unveiling how the DPOMs determine the power oscillations in AC and MTDC power systems. Moreover, this paper theoretically verifies that the DPOMs determine the behaviors of both DEPOs in MTDC systems and power oscillations between the VSCs (which adopt the DC voltage control or DC voltage droop control) and external AC systems. By analogy to LEPOs, damping torque analysis is applied to examine the stability risk of the MTDC power system. The results indicate that even if VSCs are self-stable, there is a potential risk of growing DEPOs occurring in MTDC power systems under heavy DC loads.

engineering, electrical & electronic

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the small - signal power oscillation problem in multi - terminal direct - current (MTDC) transmission systems, especially the impact of direct - current power oscillation modes (DPOMs) on system stability. Specifically:

1. **MTDC System under Master - Slave Control**:
- When master - slave control is adopted, the paper proves that there is only one DPOM in the MTDC system.
- This unique DPOM determines the direct - current power oscillations (DEPOs) and the power oscillation behavior with the external alternating - current system.

2. **MTDC System under DC Voltage Droop Control**:
- When DC voltage droop control is adopted, multi - mode oscillations may occur because there are multiple DPOMs.
- The paper analyzes how these DPOMs affect system stability and points out that under heavy - load conditions, even if the VSC itself is stable, it is possible to generate growing DEPOs.

3. **Analogy to Low - Frequency Power Oscillations (LEPOs)**:
- The paper makes an analogy between DEPOs and LEPOs in traditional alternating - current systems to better understand their behavior.
- Through this analogy, the damping torque analysis (DTA) is applied to examine the stability risks of the MTDC system.

4. **Physical Mechanism and Stability Analysis**:
- The paper reveals that negative damping is a common physical mechanism that causes DEPOs to be unstable.
- It is proposed that under heavy - load conditions, the direct - current power transmitted through the direct - current network should be appropriately limited to estimate the risks of DEPOs.

In summary, this paper aims to deeply explore the stability and potential risks of small - signal power oscillations in MTDC systems through theoretical analysis and analogy methods, and provide an evaluation method based on damping torque analysis. This helps power system engineers better understand and solve the stability problems in MTDC systems.

### Formula Summary

- **Dynamic Equations under Master - Slave Control**:
\[
V_{dc1}=V_{dc1,0}+\frac{1}{C_1}\int (I_{in1}-I_{dc1})dt
\]
\[
\Delta V_{dc1}=T_{Ms}(s)\Delta I_{in1}
\]
where \( T_{Ms}(s)=\frac{1}{m_1s^2 + m_2s + m_3} \), \( m_1 = C_1V_{dc1,0} \), \( m_2 = K_{p1}C_1 \), \( m_3 = K_{pi1}C_1V_{dc1,0} \).

- **Dynamic Equations under DC Voltage Droop Control**:
\[
V_{dcj}=V_{dcj,0}+\frac{1}{C_j}\int (I_{inj}-I_{dcj})dt
\]
\[
\Delta V_{dcj}=T_{Drj}(s)\Delta I_{inj}
\]
where \( T_{Drj}(s)=\frac{1}{K_{dj}s^2 + K_{aj}s + K_{pj}} \).

- **Damping Torque Analysis**:
\[
D(s)=\sum_{i = 1}^{N}D_i(s)
\]
where \( D_i(s) \) represents the damping torque provided by the \( i \) - th VSC.