The Lifetime Impacts of the New Deal's Youth Employment Program

Anna Aizer,Nancy Early,Shari Eli,Guido Imbens,Keyoung Lee,Adriana Lleras-Muney,Alexander Strand

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjae016

IF: 19.013

2024-06-09

The Quarterly Journal of Economics

Abstract:We study the lifetime effects of the first and largest American youth employment and training program in the U.S.—the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), 1933–1942. We match newly digitized enrollee records to Census, World War II enlistment, Social Security, and death records. We find that longer service in the CCC led to improvements in height, health status, longevity, geographic mobility, and lifetime earnings but did not improve short-term labor market outcomes including employment and wages. We address potential selection into CCC duration using several approaches, most importantly two newly developed control function approaches that leverage unbiased estimates of the short-term effects of a randomized controlled trial of Job Corps (the modern version of the CCC). Our findings suggest that short- and medium-term evaluations of employment programs underestimate impacts because they fail to capture lifetime effects and often ignore or underestimate health and longevity benefits which increase in magnitude at later ages.

economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of evaluating the lifelong impact of the largest youth employment program in American history—the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC)—on its participants. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Long-term Economic Impact**: The paper examines how the duration of participation in the CCC affects participants' lifetime income, geographic mobility, and later life status.

2. **Health and Longevity**: The paper explores whether participation in the CCC can improve participants' health and extend their lifespan.

3. **Comparison of Short-term and Long-term Effects**: The paper points out that short-term evaluations often underestimate the impact of these employment programs because they fail to capture long-term benefits, especially in terms of health and longevity.

Through detailed analysis of newly digitized historical records, including census data, World War II enlistment records, social security records, and death records, researchers found that individuals who participated in the CCC for longer periods experienced significant improvements in height, health status, longevity, geographic mobility, and lifetime income. However, these improvements were not reflected in short-term labor market performance, such as employment rates and wage levels.

In summary, the paper aims to comprehensively assess the long-term impact of the historic CCC youth employment program on participants' lives and to reveal the implications of these impacts for modern similar programs.