Abstract:The emergence of multicellularity is one of the major transitions in evolution that happened multiple times independently. During aggregative multicellularity, genetically potentially unrelated lineages cooperate to form transient multicellular groups. Unlike clonal multicellularity, aggregative multicellular organisms do not rely on kin selection instead other mechanisms maintain cooperation against cheater phenotypes that benefit from cooperators but do not contribute to groups. Spatiality with limited diffusion can facilitate group selection, as interactions among individuals are restricted to local neighbourhoods only. Selection for larger size (e.g. avoiding predation) may facilitate the emergence of aggregation, though it is unknown, whether and how much role such selection played during the evolution of aggregative multicellularity. We have investigated the effect of spatiality and the necessity of predation on the stability of aggregative multicellularity via individual-based modelling on the ecological timescale. We have examined whether aggregation facilitates the survival of cooperators in a temporally heterogeneous environment against cheaters, where only a subset of the population is allowed to periodically colonize a new, resource-rich habitat. Cooperators constitutively produce adhesive molecules to promote aggregation and propagule-formation while cheaters spare this expense to grow faster but cannot aggregate on their own, hence depending on cooperators for long-term survival. We have compared different population-level reproduction modes with and without individual selection (predation) to evaluate the different hypotheses. In a temporally homogeneous environment without propagule-based colonization, cheaters always win. Predation can benefit cooperators, but it is not enough to maintain the necessary cooperator amount in successive dispersals, either randomly or by fragmentation. Aggregation-based propagation however can ensure the adequate ratio of cooperators-to-cheaters in the propagule and is sufficient to do so even without predation. Spatiality combined with temporal heterogeneity helps cooperators via group selection, thus facilitating aggregative multicellularity. External stress selecting for larger size (e.g. predation) may facilitate aggregation, however, according to our results, it is neither necessary nor sufficient for aggregative multicellularity to be maintained when there is effective group-selection. There is a lot of debate about how and why multicellularity emerged many times independently and what factors contributed to its prevalence. There are many theories why it was advantageous to be multicellular. Factors with direct advantage for aggregation (like avoiding predation) are evident but there are factors with indirect advantages, like spatiality and temporal heterogeneity. The latter can ensure the survival of the cooperative trait through group selection, without kin recognition or selection towards larger size (predation). In our model we investigated this hypothesis. We modelled two types of cells in a temporally heterogenous, spatial environments. Cooperators can associate to form aggregates while cheaters cannot by themselves stick to others but can enjoy the benefits of the aggregate. In resource-rich environments, cooperators have a disadvantage due to slower growth, but only they can create propagules in resource-poor environments. Cheaters therefore need to piggyback propagule-forming cooperators to make it to the next rich habitat. We show that cooperators can survive due to group selection enabled by spatiality in altering environments, without any further mechanism needed.

Michener’s group-size paradox in cooperatively breeding birds

Experimental evidence that group size generates divergent benefits of cooperative breeding for male and female ostriches

The price of associating with breeders in the cooperatively breeding chestnut-crowned babbler: foraging constraints, survival and sociality

Group augmentation underlies the evolution of complex sociality in the face of environmental instability

Diminishing returns drive altruists to help extended family

Flock size increases with the diversity and abundance of local predators in an avian family

The efficacy of group selection is increased by coexistence dynamics within groups

The effect of group size on mean food intake rate in birds

Evolution of sex differences in cooperation can be explained by trade-offs with dispersal

Evolution of sex differences in cooperation: the role of trade-offs with dispersal

Family living and cooperative breeding in birds are associated with the number of avian predators

The Infertility Trap: The Fertility Costs of Group-Living in Mammalian Social Evolution

Central place foragers, prey depletion halos, and how behavioral niche partitioning promotes consumer coexistence

Group-selection via aggregative propagule-formation enables cooperative multicellularity in an individual based, spatial model

Interspecific Sociality Alters the Colonization and Extinction Rates of Birds on Subtropical Reservoir Islands.

The evolution of cooperation: an evolutionary advantage of individuals impedes the evolution of the population

Resolving the Paradox of Environmental Quality and Sociality: The Ecological Causes and Consequences of Cooperative Breeding in Two Lineages of Birds

Group composition and dynamics in American Crows: insights into an unusual cooperative breeder

Indirect genetic effects should make group size more evolvable than expected

Increase of Parental Effort with Brood Size in a Nidifugous Bird

Reproductive skew in quasisocial parasitoids: how egalitarian is cooperative brooding?