Pre-Participation Screenings Frequently Miss Occult Cardiovascular Conditions in Apparently Healthy Male Middle-Aged First-Time Marathon Runners

Inarota Laily,Tom G H Wiggers,Niels van Steijn,Nick Bijsterveld,Adrianus J Bakermans,Martijn Froeling,Sandra van den Berg-Faay,Ferdinand H de Haan,Rianne H A C M de Bruin-Bon,S Matthijs Boekholdt,R Nils Planken,Evert Verhagen,Harald T Jorstad,Tom G.H. Wiggers,Adrianus J. Bakermans,Ferdinand H. de Haan,Rianne H.A.C.M. de Bruin-Bon,S. Matthijs Boekholdt,R. Nils Planken,Harald T. Jorstad
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1159/000536553
IF: 1.9
2024-02-07
Cardiology
Abstract:Introduction: The optimal pre-participation screening strategy to identify athletes at risk for exercise-induced cardiovascular events is unknown. We therefore aimed to compare the American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) and European Society of Cardiology (ESC) pre-participation screening strategies against extensive cardiovascular evaluations in identifying high-risk individuals among 35–50-year-old apparently healthy men. Methods: We applied ACSM and ESC pre-participation screenings to 25 men participating in a study on first-time marathon running. We compared screening outcomes against medical history, physical examination, electrocardiography, blood tests, echocardiography, cardiopulmonary exercise testing, and magnetic resonance imaging. Results: ACSM screening classified all participants as “medical clearance not necessary.” ESC screening classified two participants as “high-risk.” Extensive cardiovascular evaluations revealed ≥1 minor abnormality and/or cardiovascular condition in 17 participants, including three subjects with mitral regurgitation and one with a small atrial septal defect. Eleven participants had dyslipidaemia, six had hypertension, and two had premature atherosclerosis. Ultimately, three (12%) subjects had a serious cardiovascular condition warranting sports restrictions: aortic aneurysm, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM), and myocardial fibrosis post-myocarditis. Of these three participants, only one had been identified as “high-risk” by the ESC screening (for dyslipidaemia, not HCM) and none by the ACSM screening. Conclusion: Numerous occult cardiovascular conditions are missed when applying current ACSM/ESC screening strategies to apparently healthy middle-aged men engaging in their first high-intensity endurance sports event.
cardiac & cardiovascular systems
What problem does this paper attempt to address?