Chemically Oscillating Reactions as a New Model for the Formation of Mineral Patterns in Agate Geodes and Concretions

Dominic Papineau
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/min14020203
IF: 2.5
2024-02-17
Minerals
Abstract:Agate geodes contain spheroidal patterns characterized by spectacularly coloured and circularly concentric laminations with radially aligned quartz crystals, yet the origin of these geometric patterns has remained enigmatic. Here, detailed comparisons are documented between these kinds of patterns in a selection of geodes and concretions and those produced by abiotic chemically oscillating reactions. We find strikingly comparable self-similar, fractal patterns in both natural volcanogenic geodes and sedimentary concretions as well as in these benchtop experiments. In addition, the mineralogical composition of patterns and associated organic matter point to the oxidation of organic compounds in both geodes and concretions. This process occurred during diagenetic or supergene alteration, and it is consistent with spontaneous and abiotic chemically oscillating reactions. It is concluded that the oxidation of organic acids was involved in the formation of these patterns and that these rocks indicate oxidation–reduction reactions involving organic carbon, which itself may be abiotic or biological in origin. Hence, agate geodes and concretions represent the abiotic biosignatures of possible biological origin in volcanic and sedimentary rocks.
geochemistry & geophysics,mineralogy,mining & mineral processing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is: **The formation mechanism of characteristic geometric patterns in chalcedony cavities and nodules**. Specifically, the paper focuses on the origin of the circular concentric layered structures and their color gradients inside chalcedony cavities. These structures have long been a geological mystery, especially in the context of chalcedony cavities in volcanic rocks and nodules in sedimentary rocks where organic matter is commonly present. By comparing these naturally formed structures with similar structures produced in Chemically Oscillating Reactions (COR) experiments, the authors propose a new model to explain these phenomena. The paper suggests that these structures may result from chemical oscillating reactions triggered by the oxidation of organic compounds. This process could be abiotic but may also have a biological origin. Therefore, chalcedony cavities and nodules can serve as potential biosignatures, aiding in the understanding of the origin and evolution of life on Earth.