Quantitative Evaluation and Evolution Characteristics of Consistency Level of Black Soil Conservation Policy, Taking China's Black Soil Protection Policy as an Example

Fan Zhang,Peng Han,Ling Wu,Zhanwei Tian
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/land13060800
IF: 3.905
2024-06-06
Land
Abstract:Scientifically evaluating China's black soil protection policy and exploring its evolution characteristics are crucial for promoting high-quality and efficient black soil protection projects worldwide. Utilizing the Policy Modeling Consistency (PMC) index model, the effectiveness of China's black soil protection policy system is assessed. Building upon this evaluation, the research delves into the evolution process of the black soil protection policy system, examining its dynamic characteristics across different government levels. Through the application of text mining technology and visual analysis techniques, the study explores four dimensions: keyword co-occurrence, vertical synergy calculation, policy theme identification, and policy tool analysis. The results show the following: (1) The PMC index showed a phased growth trend, and various indicators gradually improved and tended to be stable. (2) Government policies at the same level exhibit progressive evolution patterns in terms of policy keywords and themes. (3) Across different levels of government, there are hierarchical lag evolution rules observed in policy keywords and provincial policy tools. Additionally, policy keywords display vertical synergy evolution patterns. In conclusion, future black soil conservation policies need to reduce hierarchical delays, enhance the coverage and comprehensiveness of policy content, and establish a sound policy feedback mechanism. The conclusions of the study are significant for improving management approaches throughout the black soil zones of the world.
environmental studies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Aims to Solve This paper aims to address the research issues related to the effectiveness evaluation and evolutionary characteristics of China's black soil protection policies. Specifically: 1. **Policy Effectiveness Evaluation**: - Utilize the Policy Modeling Consistency (PMC) index model to evaluate the effectiveness of China's black soil protection policy system. - Identify the strengths and weaknesses of the policies through quantitative evaluation, and make timely modifications and improvements. 2. **Policy Evolution Characteristics Analysis**: - Explore the evolution process and dynamic characteristics of the black soil protection policy system, including the collaborative evolution patterns between different government levels. - Study the changes in policy keywords, policy themes, policy tools, and other dimensions to reveal the development patterns of the black soil protection policy system. 3. **Construction of a Multidimensional Analysis Framework**: - Construct a multidimensional analysis framework that includes keyword co-occurrence, vertical collaboration computation, policy theme identification, and policy tool analysis. - Use methods such as social network analysis, vertical collaboration measurement, perplexity measurement, and text similarity calculation to reveal the evolutionary characteristics and development patterns of the black soil protection policy system. 4. **Theoretical and Practical Significance**: - Provide scientific reference for subsequent policy adjustments, future trend judgments, and policy applications. - Offer theoretical foundation and practical experience for soil management in global black soil regions. In summary, this paper aims to provide a new research paradigm and theoretical foundation for optimizing and improving black soil protection policies through quantitative evaluation and multidimensional analysis.