IGG in the trenches: results of an in-depth interview study on the practice, politics, and future of investigative genetic genealogy

Christi J. Guerrini,Whitney Bash Brooks,Jill O. Robinson,Stephanie M. Fullerton,Emily Zoorob,Amy L. McGuire
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2024.111946
IF: 2.676
2024-02-02
Forensic Science International
Abstract:Investigative genetic genealogy (IGG) is a new technique for identifying criminal suspects and unidentified deceased and living persons that has sparked controversy. In a criminal case, the technique involves uploading the DNA profile left by a putative perpetrator at the crime scene to one or more direct-to-consumer genetic genealogy databases with the intention of identifying their genetic relatives and, eventually, locating them on the family tree. In 2018, IGG was used to identify the Golden State Killer, and it has since been used in hundreds of investigations in the United States. Here, we report findings from in-depth interviews with 24 U.S.-based individuals directly involved in IGG that are relevant to the technique's current practice and predicted future. Key findings include: an emphasis on restricting IGG as a conceptual and technical matter to lead generation; the rapid growth of a private and largely self-regulating industry to support IGG; general recognition of three categories of cases associated with distinct practical, ethical, and policy questions, as well as varying degrees of controversy; and the significant influence of perceived public opinion on IGG practice. The experiences and perspectives of individuals in the IGG trenches related to these and other issues are potentially useful inputs to ongoing efforts to regulate the technique.
medicine, legal
What problem does this paper attempt to address?