Why the Emerging Research on Ultra-Processed Food Matters to Health and Justice

Susan L. Prescott,Alan C. Logan,Christopher R. D'Adamo,Kathleen F. Holton,Christopher A. Lowry,John Marks,Rob Moodie,Blake Poland

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph21020120

IF: 4.614

2024-01-24

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health

Abstract:There is mounting concern over the potential harms associated with ultra-processed foods, including poor mental health and antisocial behavior. Cutting-edge research provides an enhanced understanding of biophysiological mechanisms, including microbiome pathways, and invites a historical reexamination of earlier work that investigated the relationship between nutrition and criminal behavior. Here, in this perspective article, we explore how this emergent research casts new light and greater significance on previous key observations. Despite expanding interest in the field dubbed 'nutritional psychiatry', there has been relatively little attention paid to its relevancy within criminology and the criminal justice system. Since public health practitioners, allied mental health professionals, and policymakers play key roles throughout criminal justice systems, a holistic perspective on both historical and emergent research is critical. While there are many questions to be resolved, the available evidence suggests that nutrition might be an underappreciated factor in prevention and treatment along the criminal justice spectrum. The intersection of nutrition and biopsychosocial health requires transdisciplinary discussions of power structures, industry influence, and marketing issues associated with widespread food and social inequalities. Some of these discussions are already occurring under the banner of 'food crime'. Given the vast societal implications, it is our contention that the subject of nutrition in the multidisciplinary field of criminology—referred to here as nutritional criminology—deserves increased scrutiny. Through combining historical findings and cutting-edge research, we aim to increase awareness of this topic among the broad readership of the journal, with the hopes of generating new hypotheses and collaborations.

public, environmental & occupational health,environmental sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to explore the relationship between ultra-processed foods, health, and judicial justice, and emphasizes the importance of the concept of "nutritional criminology." Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points:

1. **Harm of Ultra-Processed Foods**: Increasing research indicates that ultra-processed foods may have negative impacts on health, including mental health issues and antisocial behavior.

2. **Historical Perspective**: The paper reviews historical research on nutrition and criminal behavior, especially in the 1980s when some studies attempted to explore the potential role of nutrition in criminology. It points out that although these early studies were questioned, they provide important historical context for current research.

3. **Mechanism Research**: Recent studies suggest that the intake of ultra-processed foods is associated with low-grade systemic inflammation and affects systemic metabolites and energy absorption by altering the gut microbiota. These mechanisms help explain the adverse health effects of ultra-processed foods.

4. **Interdisciplinary Discussion**: The paper highlights the complex relationships between nutrition, biopsychosocial health, power structures, industry influence, and marketing issues. These issues are related to broader food and social inequalities.

5. **Policy Recommendations**: The paper calls for increased research on ultra-processed foods and proposes several policy recommendations, such as taxation, labeling, and reducing advertising, to decrease their widespread availability.

In summary, the paper aims to raise awareness of the importance of nutrition in the prevention and treatment within the criminal justice system and hopes to inspire new hypotheses and interdisciplinary collaboration.