Abstract:Many organisms have sex chromosomes with large non-recombining regions that expand in a stepwise manner, although the underlying reasons remain poorly understood. Recently, we proposed that recombination suppression may evolve in sex chromosomes simply because of the presence of recessive deleterious mutations within genomes. Specifically, we demonstrated that chromosomal inversions suppressing recombination and carrying by chance fewer deleterious mutations than average have a selective advantage. In addition, we showed that the permanent heterozygosity of Y-like sex chromosomes facilitates the fixation of these less-loaded inversions by a sheltering effect, i.e., by preventing the expression of recessive deleterious mutations in a homozygous state when they increase in frequency. In contrast, similar less-loaded inversions in autosomes suffer from a disadvantage in the homozygous state as their frequency increases, preventing their fixation. However, the methodology and significance of our previous study have been questioned. Here, we present new analyses that further reinforce our original claims, demonstrating that the lower-load advantage and the sheltering effect can explain the fixation of inversions on sex chromosomes over a broad range of parameter values. We show that these mechanisms promote the fixation of inversions on Y-like chromosomes at rates exceeding those expected under drift alone. We used, as a control, autosomes with a similar population size as the Y chromosome, which, we argue, provides the appropriate neutral control for the sheltering effect. We also address criticisms regarding our focus on inversions surviving the first 20 generations in a figure of our previous study, and show that these criticisms stemmed from a misunderstanding of what this figure was intended to illustrate. Including all inversions, even those that went extinct within 20 generations, does not alter our conclusions. Overall, the present study offers new support for our theory based on the combination of lower-load advantage and sheltering effect, and addresses the questions about its significance and range of applicability.

Phased assembly of neo-sex chromosomes reveals extensive Y degeneration and rapid genome evolution in Rumex hastatulus

Orthopteran Neo‐Sex Chromosomes Reveal Dynamics of Recombination Suppression and Evolution of Supergenes

Recent neo-X and Y sex chromosomes in an ant cricket

Ancestral Chromatin Configuration Constrains Chromatin Evolution on Differentiating Sex Chromosomes in Drosophila

Fragile, unfaithful and persistent Ys-on how meiosis can shape sex chromosome evolution

Eighty Million Years of Rapid Evolution of the Primate Y Chromosome

Reconstruction of the Origin of a Neo-Y Sex Chromosome and Its Evolution in the Spotted Knifejaw, Oplegnathus punctatus

Assembly of 43 human Y chromosomes reveals extensive complexity and variation

Evolution of the spinach sex-linked region within a rarely recombining pericentromeric region

Rewinding the ratchet: rare recombination locally rescues neo-W degeneration and generates plateaus of sex-chromosome divergence

Sex chromosome evolution: The classical paradigm and so much beyond

The fragile Y hypothesis: Y chromosome aneuploidy as a selective pressure in sex chromosome and meiotic mechanism evolution

Low X/Y divergence in four pairs of papaya sex-linked genes.

The asparagus genome sheds light on the origin and evolution of a young Y chromosome

Nonrandom Gene Loss from the Drosophila Miranda Neo-Y Chromosome

The Epigenome of Evolving Drosophila Neo-Sex Chromosomes: Dosage Compensation and Heterochromatin Formation

Sex-Specific Adaptation Drives Early Sex Chromosome Evolution in Drosophila

Y-chromosome Degeneration due to Speciation and Founder Effect

Chromosome-wide gene silencing initiates Y degeneration in Drosophila.

Rapid Sex Chromosome Turnover in African Clawed Frogs ( Xenopus ) and the Origins of New Sex Chromosomes

Deleterious mutations can contribute to the evolution of recombination suppression between sex chromosomes