Assessing the Susceptibility of the Xiangka Debris Flow Using Analytic Hierarchy Process, Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation Method, and Cloud Model

Yan Li,Jianguo Wang,Keping Ju,Shengyun Wei,Zhinan Wang,Jian Hu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16135392
IF: 3.9
2024-06-26
Sustainability
Abstract:The seasonal Xiangka debris flow, breaking out frequently in Xinghai County, Qinghai Province, poses a serious threat to resident safety, has significant potential economic impacts, and inflicts severe damage on the geological environment, vegetation, and land resources in the area. Therefore, a susceptibility assessment is crucial. Utilizing data from field investigations, meteorology, and remote sensing, this study devised an assessment system using 10 evaluation factors with pronounced regional characteristics as susceptibility indices. Based on data processing using ArcGIS 10.7 and MATLAB R2016B, this study assessed the susceptibility of the Xiangka debris flow using AHP, the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method, and a cloud model. The analysis results show that, based on AHP, the primary index affecting the occurrence of Xiangka debris flow is mainly source factor (0.447). The secondary indices are mainly the length ratio of the mud sand supply section (0.219), fractional vegetation cover (FVC, 0.208), and watershed area (0.192). Combined with the actual characteristics, it can be seen that the formation conditions of the Xiangka debris flow primarily encompass the following: sources such as slope erosion and accumulation at gully exits, challenging topography and terrain conducive to the accumulation of water and solid materials, and water source aspects like surface runoff from intense rainfall. Based on the fuzzy mathematical method—fuzzy coordinate method—cloud model, it is concluded that the degree of susceptibility is mild-to-moderate. The combination of these methods provides a new idea for the evaluation of debris flow susceptibility. This study can provide a theoretical basis for the layout of treatment engineering and geological disaster prevention in this area and promote the sustainable development of the ecological environment.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem this paper attempts to address is the assessment of the susceptibility of the Xiangka debris flow in Xinghai County, Qinghai Province. Specifically, the study aims to determine the formation conditions and potential risks of the Xiangka debris flow by analyzing factors such as topography, geology, and meteorology, thereby providing a theoretical basis for geological disaster prevention and sustainable development in the region. ### Main Issues: 1. **Assessing the susceptibility of the Xiangka debris flow**: Evaluate the susceptibility of the Xiangka debris flow by analyzing factors such as topography, geology, and meteorology. 2. **Identifying major influencing factors**: Determine the most significant factors affecting the occurrence of the Xiangka debris flow to implement effective prevention and control measures. 3. **Providing a theoretical basis**: Offer scientific evidence for geological disaster prevention and sustainable development in the region. ### Background Information: - The Xiangka debris flow is seasonal and frequently occurs in Xinghai County, Qinghai Province, posing a serious threat to residents' safety, the economy, and the ecological environment. - Over the past 30 years, there have been 120 debris flow events in Qinghai Province, resulting in severe casualties and economic losses. - The geological structure of the study area is loose and fragile, making it prone to surface instability and debris flow formation due to rainfall. ### Methods: - **Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)**: Used to determine the importance weights of various influencing factors. - **Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation Method**: Combines principles of fuzzy mathematics to assess the susceptibility of debris flows. - **Cloud Model**: Considers the fuzziness and randomness of evaluation indicators to provide more detailed assessment results. ### Results: - The AHP analysis results show that the main factors influencing the occurrence of the Xiangka debris flow are source area factors (0.447), followed by the length ratio of the sediment supply section (0.219), vegetation coverage (0.208), and watershed area (0.192). - The combined assessment results of the fuzzy mathematics method and the cloud model indicate that the susceptibility of the Xiangka debris flow ranges from light to moderate. ### Significance: - This study provides a scientific basis for the prevention and control of the Xiangka debris flow, aiding in the formulation of effective engineering management and geological disaster prevention measures. - It offers new ideas and methods for assessing the susceptibility of debris flows in similar regions, promoting sustainable development of the ecological environment.