Policy recommendations for a national low-carbon fuel standard

N. Pavlenko

Abstract:There has been growing interest in introducing a national low carbon fuel standard (LCFS) in the United States as a replacement for the current Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS). The RFS, a program that mandates increasing volumes of various types of biofuels over time, is not well defined by law after 2022 and has become politically divisive. A national-level low-carbon fuel standard, similar to existing policies implemented in California and Oregon, would be technology-neutral, wherein fuels would generate credits or deficits based on their greenhouse gas (GHG) intensity. Depending on how it is designed, the transition from the existing RFS to a national-level LCFS could pose new risks or exacerbate existing issues in U.S. fuels policy. Notably, it may simply accelerate demand for existing, food-based biofuels and fail to deliver its intended GHG savings. This briefing paper discusses several of the motivations behind implementing a national LCFS, evaluates key risks associated with LCFS policy design, and lastly, provides a set of recommendations to mitigate those risks and maximize the effectiveness of the policy. We recommend a complementary set of proposals that would cap the contributions of the riskiest feedstocks, such as food-based biofuels, to a national LCFS and provide targeted support for more sustainable, second-generation biofuels.

Environmental Science,Political Science,Economics