Abstract:The prenatal and neonatal periods are two of the most important developmental stages of the human brain. It is therefore crucial to understand normal brain development and how early connections are established during these periods, in order to advance the state of knowledge on altered brain development and eventually identify early brain markers of neurodevelopmental disorders and diseases. In this systematic review (Prospero ID: CRD42024511365), we compiled resting state functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies in healthy fetuses and neonates, in order to outline the main characteristics of typical development of the functional brain connectivity during the prenatal and neonatal periods. A systematic search of five databases identified a total of 12 573 articles. Of those, 28 articles met pre-established selection criteria based determined by the authors after surveying and compiling the major limitations reported within the literature. Inclusion criteria were: (1) resting state studies; (2) presentation of original results; (3) use of fMRI with minimum one Tesla; (4) a population ranging from 20 weeks of GA to term birth (around 37-42 weeks of PMA); (5) singleton pregnancy with normal development (absence of any complications known to alter brain development). Exclusion criteria were: (1) preterm studies; (2) post-mortem studies; (3) clinical or pathological studies; (4) twin studies; (5) papers with a sole focus on methodology (i.e. focused on tool and analysis development); (6) volumetric studies; (7) activation map studies; (8) cortical analysis studies; (9) conference papers. A risk of bias assessment was also done to evaluate each article's methodological rigor. 1877 participants were included across all the reviewed articles. Results consistently revealed a developmental gradient of increasing functional brain connectivity from posterior to anterior regions and from proximal-to-distal regions. A decrease in local small-world organization shortly after birth was also observed; small-world characteristics were present in fetuses and newborns, but appeared weaker in the latter group. Also, the posterior-to-anterior gradient could be associated with earlier development of the sensorimotor networks in the posterior regions while more complex higher-order networks (e.g. attention-related) mature later in the anterior regions. The main limitations of this systematic review stem from the inherent limitations of functional imaging in fetuses, mainly: unevenly distributed populations and limited sample sizes; fetal movements in the womb and other imaging obstacles; and a large voxel resolution when imaging a small brain. Another limitation specific to this review is the relatively small number of included articles compared to very a large search result, which may have led to relevant articles having been overlooked.

From sensory motor and perceptual development to primary consciousness in the fetus: converging neural, behavioral, and imaging correlates of cognition-mediated emergent transitions

Not with a "zap" but with a "beep": Measuring the origins of perinatal experience

Typical and disrupted brain circuitry for conscious awareness in full-term and preterm infants

Perceptual Awareness in Human Infants: What is the Evidence?

Markers of consciousness in infants: Towards a 'cluster-based' approach

Gradient organisation of functional connectivity within resting state networks is present from 25 weeks gestation in the human fetal brain

Trajectories of human brain functional connectome maturation across the birth transition

Functional connectivity development in the prenatal and neonatal stages measured by functional magnetic resonance imaging: A systematic review

Can we detect consciousness in newborn infants?

Early development of sleep and brain functional connectivity in term-born and preterm infants

Human Brain Organoids and Consciousness: Moral Claims and Epistemic Uncertainty

Perinatal development of structural thalamocortical connectivity

Examining the Role of Socioeconomic Status and Maternal Sensitivity in Predicting Functional Brain Network Connectivity in 5-Month-Old Infants

Development of the Fetal Brain Corticocortical Structural Network during the Second-to-Third Trimester Based on Diffusion MRI

Development of the Fetal Brain Cortico-Cortical Structural Network During the Second-to-third Trimester Based on Diffusion MRI

How do human newborns come to understand the multimodal environment?

Developmental Pattern of Individual Morphometric Similarity Network in the Human Fetal Brain

The developing brain by trimester

Functional structure of local connections and differentiation of cerebral cortex areas in the neonate

Homeostatic Feelings and the Emergence of Consciousness

Children's reasoning about a basic aspect of consciousness