The global economy's 200-year growth spurt — and what comes next

Rutger Hoekstra

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-01520-8

IF: 64.8

2024-05-25

Nature

Abstract:Can an unlimited supply of innovations and ideas maintain growth without costing the Earth? Yes, a wide-ranging book contends. Can an unlimited supply of innovations and ideas maintain growth without costing the Earth? Yes, a wide-ranging book contends.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Infinite Affluence on a Finite Planet

Claus Jacob

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16188191

IF: 3.9

2024-09-21

Sustainability

Abstract:The decades after the Second World War have seen economic growth and prosperity on an unprecedented scale. Yet this incredible turnover of raw materials and energy into goods and eventually waste has brought our planetary systems close to their limits, as witnessed most prominently, yet not exclusively, by climate change and mass extinctions. Changing towards a greener, more sustainable and circular economy without limiting our economic wealth is attractive—yet this change does not seem to be easy or speedy enough to save the planet, its eco- and social systems, and its inhabitants. In contrast, moving towards an economy less demanding on energy and raw materials, and focusing more on the pursuit of immaterial forms of satisfaction and happiness, requires an alternative form of hedonism. By cerishing quality time rather than heaps of money, and social interactions rather than material goods, even a finite planet may allow sustainable and indeed infinite forms and amounts of prosperity.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
Beyond Land-Use Intensity: Assessing Future Global Crop Productivity Growth under Different Socioeconomic Pathways

Xiaoxi Wang,Jan P. Dietrich,Hermann Lotze-Campen,Anne Biewald,Miodrag Stevanovic,Benjamin L. Bodirsky,Bernhard Brummer,Alexander Popp

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2020.120208

IF: 12

2020-01-01

Technological Forecasting and Social Change

Abstract:Productivity growth is essential to meet the increasing global agricultural demand in the future, driven by the growing world population and income. This study develops a hybrid approach to assess future global crop productivity in a holistic way using different productivity measures and improves the understanding of productivity implications of socioeconomic factors by contrasting different shared socioeconomic pathway assumptions. The results show that the global productivity is likely to continue to grow, whereas the productivity growth varies pronouncedly among different future socioeconomic conditions. The fast growth of total factor and partial factor productivity can be reached when slow population growth and high economic growth entail moderate food demand and low investment risks. In contrast, high population growth and low economic growth could lead to relatively high land-use intensity due to the extreme pressure on agricultural production, however, associated with low total factor productivity growth. The model results indicate that the ratio of the total factor productivity growth to cropland expansion has significant impacts on food prices, with increasing prices when cropland increases faster than productivity, and vice versa. Investing in productivity improvement appears to be an effective means of ensuring food availability and sparing cropland, which can contribute to the achievement of sustainable development goals.
Infinite Growth: A Curse or a Blessing?

Gennady Shkliarevsky

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.33330.89287

2022-01-25

Abstract:The article discusses the controversy over infinite growth. It analyzes the two dominant perspectives on economic growth and finds them based on a limited and subjective view of reality. An examination of the principal aspects of economic growth (economic activity, value, and value creation) helps to understand what fuels economic growth. The article also discusses the correlations between production, consumption, as well as resources and population dynamics. The article finds that infinite and exponential economic growth is essential for the survival of our civilization.

General Economics
Can we predict long-run economic growth?

Timothy J. Garrett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1211.3102

2012-11-14

Abstract:For those concerned with the long-term value of their accounts, it can be a challenge to plan in the present for inflation-adjusted economic growth over coming decades. Here, I argue that there exists an economic constant that carries through time, and that this can help us to anticipate the more distant future: global economic wealth has a fixed link to civilization's overall rate of energy consumption from all sources; the ratio of these two quantities has not changed over the past 40 years that statistics are available. Power production and wealth rise equally quickly because civilization, like any other system in the universe, must consume and dissipate its energy reserves in order to sustain its current size. One perspective might be that financial wealth must ultimately collapse as we deplete our energy reserves. However, we can also expect that highly aggregated quantities like global wealth have inertia, and that growth rates must persist. Exceptionally rapid innovation in the two decades following 1950 allowed for unprecedented acceleration of inflation-adjusted rates of return. But today, real innovation rates are more stagnant. This means that, over the coming decade or so, global GDP and wealth should rise fairly steadily at an inflation-adjusted rate of about 2.2% per year.

General Finance,Physics and Society
Economic Growth in the Age of Ubiquitous Threats: How Global Risks are Reshaping Growth Theory

Orlando Gomes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/econ-2022-0059

2024-01-01

ECONOMICS

Abstract:Abstract One of the most outstanding accomplishments of the economic science over the last decades is the development of a sound and coherent theory of economic growth. Research in growth theory has demonstrated that significant and systematic increases in well-being are attainable whenever the right formula is implemented. When combined with efficiency, the ingredients of this formula – innovation, the diffusion of ideas, and human capital accumulation – can drive the economy toward a virtuous path of sustained growth. Notwithstanding, this is an overly optimistic view of growth that does not account for the many obstacles that the creation of wealth may encounter. The current essay surveys cutting-edge research on growth theory to conclude in favor of a paradigm shift: the main concern is no longer just with how to correctly combine production inputs, but with how their efficient use is eventually hampered by a large collection of worldwide risks and threats. Global risks come in many shapes (they can be classified as economic, environmental, geopolitical, societal, and technological) but, in any case, they call for a reexamination of growth theory.

economics
Energetic Limits to Economic Growth

James H. Brown,William R. Burnside,Ana D. Davidson,John P. DeLong,William C. Dunn,Marcus J. Hamilton,Norman Mercado-Silva,Jeffrey C. Nekola,Jordan G. Okie,William H. Woodruff,Wenyun Zuo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1525/bio.2011.61.1.7

2011-01-01

Abstract:The human population and economy have grown exponentially and now have impacts on climate, ecosystem processes, and biodiversity far exceeding those of any other species. Like all organisms, humans are subject to natural laws and are limited by energy and other resources. In this article, we use a macroecological approach to integrate perspectives of physics, ecology, and economics with an analysis of extensive global data to show how energy imposes fundamental constraints on economic growth and development. We demonstrate a positive scaling relationship between per capita energy use and per capita gross domestic product (GDP) both across nations and within nations over time. Other indicators of socioeconomic status and ecological impact are correlated with energy use and GDP. We estimate global energy consumption for alternative future scenarios of population growth and standards of living. Large amounts of energy will be required to fuel economic growth, increase standards of living, and lift developing nations out of poverty.
Long-run evolution of the global economy - Part 2: Hindcasts of innovation and growth

Timothy J. Garrett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1601.00233

2016-01-02

General Finance

Abstract:Long-range climate forecasts use integrated assessment models to link the global economy to greenhouse gas emissions. This paper evaluates an alternative economic framework outlined in part 1 of this study (Garrett, 2014) that approaches the global economy using purely physical principles rather than explicitly resolved societal dynamics. If this model is initialized with economic data from the 1950s, it yields hindcasts for how fast global economic production and energy consumption grew between 2000 and 2010 with skill scores > 90 % relative to a model of persistence in trends. The model appears to attain high skill partly because there was a strong impulse of discovery of fossil fuel energy reserves in the mid-twentieth century that helped civilization to grow rapidly as a deterministic physical response. Forecasting the coming century may prove more of a challenge because the effect of the energy impulse appears to have nearly run its course. Nonetheless, an understanding of the external forces that drive civilization may help development of constrained futures for the coupled evolution of civilization and climate during the Anthropocene.
Limits to green growth and the dynamics of innovation

Salvador Pueyo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1904.09586

2019-04-21

Theoretical Economics

Abstract:Central to the official "green growth" discourse is the conjecture that absolute decoupling can be achieved with certain market instruments. This paper evaluates this claim focusing on the role of technology, while changes in GDP composition are treated elsewhere. Some fundamental difficulties for absolute decoupling, referring specifically to thermodynamic costs, are identified through a stylized model based on empirical knowledge on innovation and learning. Normally, monetary costs decrease more slowly than production grows, and this is unlikely to change should monetary costs align with thermodynamic costs, except, potentially, in the transition after the price reform. Furthermore, thermodynamic efficiency must eventually saturate for physical reasons. While this model, as usual, introduces technological innovation just as a source of efficiency, innovation also creates challenges: therefore, attempts to sustain growth by ever-accelerating innovation collide also with the limited reaction capacity of people and institutions. Information technology could disrupt innovation dynamics in the future, permitting quicker gains in eco-efficiency, but only up to saturation and exacerbating the downsides of innovation. These observations suggest that long-term sustainability requires much deeper transformations than the green growth discourse presumes, exposing the need to rethink scales, tempos and institutions, in line with ecological economics and the degrowth literature.
Entropy and the Limits to Growth

Reiner Kümmel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/e26060489

IF: 2.738

2024-06-01

Entropy

Abstract:In its business-as-usual scenario, the 1972 Club-of-Rome report—The Limits to Growth—describes the collapse of the world economy around the year 2030, either because of the scarcity of natural resources or because of pollution. Mainstream economists, the high priests of secular societies, condemned it fiercely. Their gospel of perpetual economic growth, during which technological progress would solve all problems, promises a bright future for all mankind. On the other hand, engineers, natural scientists, and mathematicians realized that the breakdown scenario is due to the inclusion of the First and the Second Law of Thermodynamics in the Club-of-Rome's world model. According to these laws, nothing happens in the world without energy conversion and entropy production. In 1865, Rudolph Clausius, the discoverer of entropy, published the laws as the constitution of the universe. Entropy is the physical measure of disorder. Without a proper understanding of energy and entropy in the economy, all efforts to achieve sustainability will fail.

physics, multidisciplinary
Thermodynamics of long-run economic innovation and growth

Timothy J. Garrett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1306.3554

2013-06-15

General Finance

Abstract:This article derives prognostic expressions for the evolution of globally aggregated economic wealth, productivity, inflation, technological change, innovation and growth. The approach is to treat civilization as an open, non-equilibrium thermodynamic system that dissipates energy and diffuses matter in order to sustain existing circulations and to further its material growth. Appealing to a prior result that established a fixed relationship between a very general representation of global economic wealth and rates of global primary energy consumption, physically derived expressions for economic quantities follow. The analysis suggests that wealth can be expressed in terms of the length density of civilization's networks and the availability of energy resources. Rates of return on wealth are accelerated by energy reserve discovery, improvements to human and infrastructure longevity, and a more common culture, or a lowering of the amount of energy required to diffuse raw materials into civilization's bulk. According to a logistic equation, rates of return are slowed by past growth, and if rates of return approach zero, such "slowing down" makes civilization fragile with respect to externally imposed network decay. If past technological change has been especially rapid, then civilization is particularly vulnerable to newly unfavorable conditions that might force a switch into a mode of accelerating collapse.
Introduction: the Art of Engineering Prosperity in Unlikely Places

Justin Yifu Lin,Célestin Monga

DOI: https://doi.org/10.23943/princeton/9780691192338.003.0001

2019-01-01

Abstract:This chapter provides a methodological approach that draws lessons and insights from economic history and theory and uses empirics from economic analysis and policy practice. It starts with an observation of the increasingly globalized world economy in which technological development allows the use of factors of production in locations that maximize returns and utility, and countries gain mutually by trading with each other if their strategies focus on revealed and latent comparative advantage. By following carefully selected lead countries, latecomers can emulate the leader–follower, flying-geese pattern that has well served economies since the eighteenth century. The prospects for sustained and inclusive growth are even greater for low-income economies that enjoy the benefits of backwardness. The chapter advocates implementing viable strategies to capture new opportunities for industrialization, which can enable low-income economies to set forth on a dynamic path of structural change and lead to poverty reduction and prosperity.
No way out? The double-bind in seeking global prosperity alongside mitigated climate change

Timothy J. Garrett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/esd-3-1-2012

2012-01-07

Abstract:In a prior study, I introduced a simple economic growth model designed to be consistent with general thermodynamic laws. Unlike traditional economic models, civilization is viewed only as a well-mixed global whole with no distinction made between individual nations, economic sectors, labor, or capital investments. At the model core is an observationally supported hypothesis that the global economy's current rate of primary energy consumption is tied through a constant to a very general representation of its historically accumulated wealth. Here, this growth model is coupled to a linear formulation for the evolution of globally well-mixed atmospheric CO2 concentrations. While very simple, the coupled model provides faithful multi-decadal hindcasts of trajectories in gross world product (GWP) and CO2. Extending the model to the future, the model suggests that the well-known IPCC SRES scenarios substantially underestimate how much CO2 levels will rise for a given level of future economic prosperity. For one, global CO2 emission rates cannot be decoupled from wealth through efficiency gains. For another, like a long-term natural disaster, future greenhouse warming can be expected to act as an inflationary drag on the real growth of global wealth. For atmospheric CO2 concentrations to remain below a "dangerous" level of 450 ppmv, model forecasts suggest that there will have to be some combination of an unrealistically rapid rate of energy decarbonization and nearly immediate reductions in global civilization wealth. Effectively, it appears that civilization may be in a double-bind. If civilization does not collapse quickly this century, then CO2 levels will likely end up exceeding 1000 ppmv; but, if CO2 levels rise by this much, then the risk is that civilization will gradually tend towards collapse.

Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics,Physics and Society
The Schumpeterian Growth Theory:A Survey

G. Iutang

Abstract:The birth of the Schumpeterian Growth Theory in the 1990s has made a great contribution to the literature of economic growth.This theory gives us a new explanation for endogenous technological change,as well as provides us a good framework through which we can analyze other problems.The essential feature of this theory is that technological change and growth are generated by endogenous RD investment and innovation.This paper reviews the literature over the last twenty years and points out new directions for the future.

Economics
Assessing the dynamic impact of natural resource utilization, technological innovation, and environmental regulations on OECD economic growth and globalization

Kashif Raza,Yufeng Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-024-05741-9

IF: 4.08

2024-11-29

Environment Development and Sustainability

Abstract:The present study aims to explore the impact of natural resource utilization, technological innovations, and environmental regulations on economic growth and globalization across 27 OECD countries over 30 years from 1990 to 2020. Using recently developed panel data techniques, the analysis provides novel insights into both short- and long-term dynamics. The empirical results indicate that a 10% increase in technological innovation leads to an approximate 2.5% rise in economic growth, while environmental regulations, in the short run, contribute to a 1.8% increase in globalization. However, the effects of globalization on economic growth are negative, with a reduction of approximately 3% at various time lags, highlighting the potential trade-offs between openness and domestic economic performance. It also reveals that inflation negatively impacts economic growth but positively affects globalization indicators, showing divergent macroeconomic effects. The findings further suggest that technological innovations are crucial in promoting both economic growth and globalization, thereby demonstrating the importance of policy-driven research and development initiatives. In the longer term, while environmental regulations have an inverse relationship with economic growth, their impact is not statistically significant, whereas they continue to support globalization significantly. Our findings contribute to the broader understanding of the complex interactions between economic policies, resource utilization, and sustainability. This study offer valuable insights for policymakers aiming to balance economic growth with environmental sustainability and technological progress.

environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology
Energy Limits to the Gross Domestic Product on Earth

Andreas M. Hein,Jean-Baptiste Rudelle

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2005.05244

2020-05-11

Physics and Society

Abstract:Once carbon emission neutrality and other sustainability goals have been achieved, a widespread assumption is that economic growth at current rates can be sustained beyond the 21st century. However, even if we achieve these goals, this article shows that the overall size of Earth's global economy is facing an upper limit purely due to energy and thermodynamic factors. For that, we break down global warming into two components: the greenhouse gas effect and heat dissipation from energy consumption related to economic activities. For the temperature increase due to greenhouse gas emissions, we take 2 {\deg}C and 5 {\deg}C as our lower and upper bounds. For the warming effect of heat dissipation related to energy consumption, we use a simplified model for global warming and an extrapolation of the historical correlation between global gross domestic product (GDP) and primary energy production. Combining the two effects, we set the acceptable global warming temperature limit to 7 {\deg}C above pre-industrial levels. We develop four scenarios, based on the viability of large-scale deployment of carbon-neutral energy sources. Our results indicate that for a 2% annual GDP growth, the upper limit will be reached at best within a few centuries, even in favorable scenarios where new energy sources such as fusion power are deployed on a massive scale. We conclude that unless GDP can be largely decoupled from energy consumption, thermodynamics will put a hard cap on the size of Earth's economy. Further economic growth would necessarily require expanding economic activities into space.
Global Effects of Innovation and Technology

Rajagopal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137366788_11

2014-01-01

Abstract:Globalization promotes transformation in the business environment and consumer culture along the dimensions of economic geography, which can be evidenced by the growth in urban areas, shorter travel distances as businesses migrate closer to denser centers of population, and as they generate competition between firms to take advantage of scale and trade in specialized products. Firms prepare for going global by providing convenience to consumers as they search for products, buying through technology platforms, and settling payments online. Such firms also aim to boost available knowledge on products and services, and trigger the impulse to shop. The chapter demonstrates that multinational firms have been slow to understand consumers in the developing world and, as a result, they have been vulnerable to local competitors that know how their shoppers think, what they crave, and how they buy. The discussion also addresses issues relating to knowledge-sharing and building customer loyalty.
Economic Growth Dividends from Global Book Production: Recent Evidence Around the Pandemic

Rajeev K. Goel,James R. Jones,Salvatore Capasso

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13132-024-02460-4

IF: 1.815

2024-11-28

Journal of the Knowledge Economy

Abstract:This paper uses recent global data on book production to study their impacts on economic growth. Books are key inputs in human capital formation and knowledge flows/continuity, which impact economic growth. Our results, using data from nearly 100 nations over 2018–2021, show that books positively contribute to economic growth. This is true whether total books deposited in recognized repositories are used or when they are normalized by population. E-books are also shown to complement the effects of conventional books. The positive growth dividends over a period that encompasses the recent pandemic are insightful. In other results, internet access (and the degree of globalization) has complementary growth effects. Finally, the effects of some of the growth influences are shown to vary across the least- and most-growing nations.

economics
Innovation and Sustainable Development: Management Strategies for Driving Future Economic Growth

Bowen Deng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54254/2754-1169/93/20241107

2024-06-21

Abstract:Innovation and sustainable development make up for the formidable partnership that has immense ability to spur the economic growth and solve many problems facing the world today. Based on this integrative approach, it involves the application of advanced technologies, use of eco-responsibility policies and materials and partnerships with various stakeholders. This balancing act of how innovation and sustainability can be interconnected allows for resource-efficient, sustainable solutions to foster productivity and profitability as well as opportunities for new, future business and growth that create value for economic, environmental and social systems. On renewable energy systems and Intelligent waste management to circular business models, and Smart city projects, this shift is changing organizational dynamics, which was earlier set-in-mould once and for-all, prompting directors to come up with innovative ideas. Stemming from the spirit of change, enhanced by leaders vision and employees innovation, as well as cooperation with other sectors, companies can ensure phenomenal levels of sustainable development, lessen ecological deterioration, and enhance opportunities in this sphere. Through collective commitment and collaboration of governments, industries, academia, and civil society, this integrated connection between innovation and sustainability presents the only sustainable model in the long-term formula for a prosperous economy and a more sustainable planet.
The quest for prosperity: how developing economies can take off

Justin Yifu Lin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5860/choice.50-3378

2013-01-01

Choice Reviews Online

Abstract:How can developing countries grow their economies? Most answers to this question center on what the rich world should or shouldn't do for the poor world. In The Quest for Prosperity, Justin Yifu Lin--the first non-Westerner to be chief economist of the World Bank--focuses on what developing nations can do to help themselves. Since the end of the Second World War, prescriptions for economic growth have come and gone. Often motivated more by ideology than practicality, these blueprints have had mixed success on the ground. Drawing lessons from history, economic analysis, and practice, Lin examines how the countries that have succeeded in developing their own economies have actually done it. He shows that economic development is a process of continuous technological innovation, industrial upgrading, and structural change driven by how countries harness their land, labor, capital, and infrastructure. Countries need to identify and facilitate the development of those industries where they have a comparative advantage--where they can produce products most effectively--and use them as a basis for development. At the same time, states need to recognize the power of markets, limiting the role of government to allow firms to flourish and lead the process of technological innovation and industrial upgrading. By following this new structural economics framework, Lin shows how even the poorest nations can grow at eight percent or more continuously for several decades, significantly reduce poverty, and become middle- or even high-income countries in the span of one or two generations. Interwoven with insights, observations, and stories from Lin's travels as chief economist of the World Bank and his reflections on China's rise, this book provides a road map and hope for those countries engaged in their own quest for prosperity.
Stability of Zero-growth Economics Analysed with a Minskyan Model

Adam B. Barrett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2017.10.014

IF: 6.536

2018-04-01

Ecological Economics

Abstract:As humanity is becoming increasingly confronted by Earth's finite biophysical limits, there is increasing interest in questions about the stability and equitability of a zero-growth capitalist economy, most notably: if one maintains a positive interest rate for loans, can a zero-growth economy be stable? This question has been explored on a few different macroeconomic models, and both ‘yes' and ‘no’ answers have been obtained. However, economies can become unstable whether or not there is ongoing underlying growth in productivity with which to sustain growth in output. Here we attempt, for the first time, to assess via a model the relative stability of growth versus no-growth scenarios. The model employed draws from Keen's model of the Minsky financial instability hypothesis. The analysis focuses on dynamics as opposed to equilibrium, and scenarios of growth and no-growth of output (GDP) are obtained by tweaking a productivity growth input parameter. We confirm that, with or without growth, there can be both stable and unstable scenarios. To maintain stability, firms must not change their debt levels or target debt levels too quickly. Further, according to the model, the wages share is higher for zero-growth scenarios, although there are more frequent substantial drops in employment.

economics,environmental studies,environmental sciences,ecology

The global economy's 200-year growth spurt — and what comes next

Infinite Affluence on a Finite Planet

Beyond Land-Use Intensity: Assessing Future Global Crop Productivity Growth under Different Socioeconomic Pathways

Infinite Growth: A Curse or a Blessing?

Can we predict long-run economic growth?

Economic Growth in the Age of Ubiquitous Threats: How Global Risks are Reshaping Growth Theory

Energetic Limits to Economic Growth

Long-run evolution of the global economy - Part 2: Hindcasts of innovation and growth

Limits to green growth and the dynamics of innovation

Entropy and the Limits to Growth

Thermodynamics of long-run economic innovation and growth

Introduction: the Art of Engineering Prosperity in Unlikely Places

No way out? The double-bind in seeking global prosperity alongside mitigated climate change

The Schumpeterian Growth Theory:A Survey

Assessing the dynamic impact of natural resource utilization, technological innovation, and environmental regulations on OECD economic growth and globalization

Energy Limits to the Gross Domestic Product on Earth

Global Effects of Innovation and Technology

Economic Growth Dividends from Global Book Production: Recent Evidence Around the Pandemic

Innovation and Sustainable Development: Management Strategies for Driving Future Economic Growth

The quest for prosperity: how developing economies can take off

Stability of Zero-growth Economics Analysed with a Minskyan Model