Abstract:Bilingualism has been identified as a potential cognitive factor linked to delayed onset of dementia as well as boosting executive functions in healthy individuals. However, more recently, this claim has been called into question following several failed replications. It remains unclear whether these contradictory findings reflect how bilingualism is defined between studies, or methodological limitations when measuring the bilingual effect. One key issue is that despite the claims that bilingualism yields general protection to cognitive processes (i.e., the cognitive reserve hypothesis), studies reporting putative bilingual differences are often focused on domain specific experimental paradigms. This study chose a broader approach, by considering the consequences of bilingualism on a wide range of cognitive functions within individuals. We utilised 19 measures of different cognitive functions commonly associated with bilingual effects, to form a “cognitive profile” for 215 non-clinical participants. We recruited Welsh speakers, who as a group of bilinguals were highly homogeneous, as means of isolating the bilingualism criterion. We sought to determine if such analyses would independently classify bilingual/monolingual participant groups based on emergent patterns driven by collected cognitive profiles, such that population differences would emerge. Multiple predictive models were trained to independently recognise the cognitive profiles of bilinguals, older adults (60-90 years of age) and higher education attainment. Despite managing to successfully classify cognitive profiles based on age and education, the model failed to differentiate between bilingual and monolingual cognitive ability at a rate greater than that of chance. Repeated modelling using alternative definitions of bilingualism, and just the older adults, yielded similar results. In all cases then, using our “bottom–up” analytical approach, there was no evidence that bilingualism as a variable indicated differential cognitive performance – as a consequence, we conclude that bilinguals are not cognitively different from their monolingual counterparts, even in older demographics. We suggest that studies that have reported a bilingual advantage (typically recruiting immigrant populations) could well have confounded other key variables that may be driving reported advantages. We recommend that future research refine the machine learning methods used in this study to further investigate the complex relationship between bilingualism and cognition.

The Advantages of Bilingualism Debate

The Advantages of Bilingualism Debate

Meta-Analysis Reveals a Bilingual Advantage That Is Dependent on Task and Age

Bilingualism: consequences for mind and brain

Cognitive Advantage in Bilingualism

A Bilingual Advantage? An Appeal for a Change in Perspective and Recommendations for Future Research

Reshaping the mind: The benefits of bilingualism.

Does bilingualism protect against dementia? A meta-analysis

Cultural Effects Rather Than a Bilingual Advantage in Cognition: A Review and an Empirical Study

The Cognitive Science of Bilingualism.

Bilingualism: The good, the bad, and the indifferent

Bilingualism (multilingualism) Helps Resist Alzheimer's Disease?

Bilingualism and Cognitive Reserve: A Critical Overview and a Plea for Methodological Innovations

On the Need for Theoretically Guided Approaches to Possible Bilingual Advantages: An Evaluation of the Potential Loci in the Language and Executive Control Systems

Does the Bilingual Advantage in Cognitive Control Exist and If So, What Are Its Modulating Factors? A Systematic Review

Lifelong Bilingualism Functions as an Alternative Intervention for Cognitive Reserve Against Alzheimer's Disease

Clear Theories Are Needed to Interpret Differences: Perspectives on the Bilingual Advantage Debate

Bilingual disadvantages are systematically compensated by bilingual advantages across tasks and populations

Can Machines Find the Bilingual Advantage? Machine Learning Algorithms Find No Evidence to Differentiate Between Lifelong Bilingual and Monolingual Cognitive Profiles

Is there a bilingual advantage on interference-control tasks? A multiverse meta-analysis of global reaction time and interference cost

Bilingualism, Aging, and Cognitive Control: Evidence From the Simon Task.