Abstract:Decision trees (DTs) epitomize the ideal of interpretability of machine learning (ML) models. The interpretability of decision trees motivates explainability approaches by so-called intrinsic interpretability, and it is at the core of recent proposals for applying interpretable ML models in high-risk applications. The belief in DT interpretability is justified by the fact that explanations for DT predictions are generally expected to be succinct. Indeed, in the case of DTs, explanations correspond to DT paths. Since decision trees are ideally shallow, and so paths contain far fewer features than the total number of features, explanations in DTs are expected to be succinct, and hence interpretable. This paper offers both theoretical and experimental arguments demonstrating that, as long as interpretability of decision trees equates with succinctness of explanations, then decision trees ought not be deemed interpretable. The paper introduces logically rigorous path explanations and path explanation redundancy, and proves that there exist functions for which decision trees must exhibit paths with explanation redundancy that is arbitrarily larger than the actual path explanation. The paper also proves that only a very restricted class of functions can be represented with DTs that exhibit no explanation redundancy. In addition, the paper includes experimental results substantiating that path explanation redundancy is observed ubiquitously in decision trees, including those obtained using different tree learning algorithms, but also in a wide range of publicly available decision trees. The paper also proposes polynomial-time algorithms for eliminating path explanation redundancy, which in practice require negligible time to compute. Thus, these algorithms serve to indirectly attain irreducible, and so succinct, explanations for decision trees. Furthermore, the paper includes novel results related with duality and enumeration of explanations, based on using SAT solvers as witness-producing NP-oracles.

Revisiting 2–3 red–black trees with a pedagogically sound yet efficient deletion algorithm: parity-seeking

A symbolic-arithmetic for teaching double-black node removal in red-black trees

A Verified Cost Analysis of Joinable Red-Black Trees

Grand-children weight-balanced binary search trees

Greedy Is an Almost Optimal Deque

Optimized Deletion From an AVL Tree

B-Treaps Revised: Write Efficient Randomized Block Search Trees with High Load

Efficient Computation of the Tree Edit Distance

Efficient top-down updates in AVL trees

Bottom-up Rebalancing Binary Search Trees by Flipping a Coin

Optimal Tree Decompositions Revisited: A Simpler Linear-Time FPT Algorithm

Search Problems in Trees with Symmetries: near optimal traversal strategies for individualization-refinement algorithms

Ranked Subtree Prune and Regraft

Root-to-Leaf Scheduling in Write-Optimized Trees

Extremal Distances for Subtree Transfer Operations in Binary Trees

On Tackling Explanation Redundancy in Decision Trees

Remote control system of a binary tree of switches -- II. balancing for a perfect binary tree

A New Pruning Method for Solving Decision Trees and Game Trees

DeltaTree: A Practical Locality-aware Concurrent Search Tree

Revisiting Tree Isomorphism: An Algorithmic Bric-à-Brac

A Scalable Method for Readable Tree Layouts