Effects of wind on the stability of explosive eruption plumes

Tyler Paladino,Shannon Kobs Nawotniak,Bryan Nicholson,Suniti Karunatillake
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvolgeores.2024.108036
IF: 2.986
2024-02-01
Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research
Abstract:Explosive volcanic eruptions can produce eruption plumes and pyroclastic density currents that can severely damage life and property. While many factors influence eruption plume stability, including mass eruption rate, grain size distribution, and environmental factors, the role of wind is complicated, with evidence for wind as both a stabilizing and destabilizing factor. Here we use the Active Tracer High-resolution Atmospheric Model (ATHAM) to simulate 980 plumes with differing eruptive parameters, atmospheric profiles, and wind conditions to isolate how and when wind can lead to column collapse. We analyze these simulations via a novel method that provides stability percentage via an ash flux up vs down metric. We found that high winds decrease plume stability if the wind acts on the jet thrust-convective rise transition region of the plume, also reducing the amount of ash being loaded into the atmosphere; otherwise, high wind speeds affect plume height and shape, but without measurable effects on stability. Although very powerful (≥ ∼107 kg/s) eruptions are largely unaffected by wind at any altitude, pyroclastic density currents being formed tend to be deflected in the downwind direction in wind fields >25 m/s, regardless of mass eruption rate. Advection Diffusion Sedimentation (ADS) models and deposit inversions of eruptions in low altitude winds could potentially be improved by accounting for the diminished atmospheric ash loading in these scenarios. Plain language Explosive volcanic eruptions, like those produced at Mt. St. Helens or Mt. Vesuvius, can produce hazards such as plumes of ash or pyroclastic density currents, which are hot, fast-moving mixtures of ash, gas, and rock that travel downslope of the volcano. Pyroclastic density currents can form when an explosive eruption's plume collapses into a ground-hugging flow rather than rising into the atmosphere. Volcanologists have a good understanding of why plumes collapse into pyroclastic density currents except for the effects of wind. Using state-of-the-art plume modeling software, we simulated hundreds of eruptions in varying degrees and altitudes of wind to understand how wind may lead to a plume collapsing. We found that wind can indeed cause plume collapse, but that the altitude of that wind must be close to the top of the volcano. We also found that when an eruption is very powerful, wind has little effect on the plume. Finally, we found that wind will tend to deflect pyroclastic density currents in the downwind direction. This study has implications for near-real-time ash dispersal modeling software improvements and for more accurate studies of ancient volcanic deposits.
geosciences, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?