Hesitancy among Iranian nursing students regarding future career trajectory: a qualitative analysis

Farnoosh Shafiei,Mostafa Amini-Rarani,Koen Ponnet,Maryam Moeeni

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12960-023-00881-x

IF: 4.5

2024-01-02

Human Resources for Health

Abstract:Abstract Background The shortage of skilled nurses is a major concern for health systems worldwide. This may be partly due to the hesitancy of some nurses to enter or remain in the nursing career. This shortage consequently reduces the quality of standard patient care, increases patients’ length of stay in a hospital, increases medical costs, and results in patients’ dissatisfaction. This study aimed to explore hesitancy among senior undergraduate nursing students to pursue a career in nursing. Methods This qualitative study adopted a thematic analysis approach. The population comprised senior undergraduate nursing students at Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Iran, who indicated that they were hesitant to pursue a career in nursing. The study sampling was performed from May 2021 till February 2022 and continued until data saturation. Twenty-four interviews were conducted with the selected students. The attributes related to hesitancy among senior undergraduate nursing students to pursue a career in nursing were extracted as themes and sub-themes. Results Four themes were identified: academic idiosyncrasies, individual characteristics, poor nursing market regulations (sub-themes: nursing as a tough and intense career, and unfavorable employment contracts), and the peculiarities of the workplace (sub-themes: conflict within work environment, and barriers to professional nursing practice). Conclusions The findings of this study showed that senior undergraduate nursing students weigh their future career options from various academic, personal, professional, and work environment dimensions. The findings provide new insights for decision makers to design and implement innovative strategies to promote retention in nursing careers. We recommend to provide academic counseling for all students and applicants of nursing before they enter the nursing education. Furthermore, we suggest to improve study and work environments, and to implement incentive programs to enhance enthusiasm of nursing students for pursuing a nursing career.

health policy & services,industrial relations & labor

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the reasons for the hesitation of senior nursing students at Iran University of Medical Sciences to pursue a nursing career in the future. Specifically, the study identifies the specific factors contributing to these students' hesitation towards the nursing profession through qualitative analysis. The study finds that the main reasons can be summarized into the following four themes:

1. **Academic Characteristics**:
- Professors lack enthusiasm and supportive attitudes towards students, sometimes even using negative language to describe the nursing profession, which leads to students' hesitation about pursuing a nursing career.
- There is a distant relationship between professors and students, with professors not paying sufficient attention to students' personal and academic issues.

2. **Personal Characteristics**:
- Some students believe their personality is not suitable for the nursing profession, such as disliking the hospital environment or feeling incapable of handling unfortunate events in nursing work.
- Some students are more interested in other health professions (such as medicine, dentistry, and pharmacy), thus hesitating about the nursing profession.

3. **Adverse Regulations in the Nursing Market**:
- The nursing profession involves high work intensity, high pressure, and a lack of sufficient rest time and holidays.
- Employment contract conditions are poor, including low wages, job instability, and unreasonable employment conditions (such as marital status and residence requirements).

4. **Characteristics of the Work Environment**:
- There are conflicts in the work environment, including conflicts among nurses, between nurses and management or doctors, and poor attitudes of patients towards nurses.
- There is a lack of autonomy and space for innovation in nursing practice, with repetitive and monotonous work content.

The research results provide new insights that help decision-makers design and implement innovative strategies to improve the retention rate of nursing students. It is recommended to provide academic counseling before students enter nursing education, improve the learning and working environment, and implement incentive programs to enhance students' enthusiasm for pursuing a nursing career.