Prevalence of Subjective and Objective Sleep Disturbances: Comparing Persons with Schizophrenia and Non-Psychiatric Comparisons
Jerry McDonald,Ellen Lee,Stephanie Ibrahim,Lisa Eyler
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jagp.2024.01.211
IF: 7.996
2024-02-22
American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry
Abstract:Introduction Sleep disturbances have been long documented in people with schizophrenia (PwS) and are associated with poor outcomes such as depression and suicidality. Past studies suggest that worse self-reported sleep and poor objective sleep will predict worse depression outcomes among PwS and non-psychiatric participants. Few studies have examined the effects of both subjective and objective sleep measures on depressive symptoms among both PwS and NCs. Understanding these relationships may aid in identifying risk factors and treatment targets for depression among PwS and NCs. In this study, we examined the effects of subjective and objective (assessed by a fitness tracker) sleep measures on depressive symptoms among PwS. We hypothesized that 1) Poor subjective sleep would be associated with depression in both PwS and NCs. 2) Shorter total sleep time, later bed-times/wake-times and more variable bed-times/wake-times would be associated with depression in both PwS and NCs, 3) People with poor subjective sleep quality will also have worse objective sleep measures (shorter total sleep time, later and more variable bed-times and wake-times). Methods The sample included 375 adult participants ages 30 to 70, 44% were PwS and 56% were NCs. Depression was measured by the Calgary Depression Scale for Depression for Schizophrenia. Subjective sleep quality was measured by the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), a 17-item self-report inventory on sleep quality as perceived by the respondent over the past month. Poor subjective sleep quality was defined as a global PSQI score >5. Objective sleep variables were assessed using a Fitbit Charge 5 smartwatch worn for 6 days. Objective sleep measures included mean total sleep time, bed-times, wake-times and standard deviation of total sleep time, bed-times, and wake-times. Analyses included T-tests, Chi-square tests and general linear models. Results The sample included 165 PwS and 210 NCs, of which 52% were women and mean age was 53.6 years. We found that 63% of PwS and 53% of NCs had poor subjective sleep quality. Poor subjective sleep quality was associated with depression among PwS and NCs (B=0.253, SE=0.082, t=3.07, p<0.005) for PwS and (B= 0.218, SE = 0.037, t=5.83, p<0.001) for NC's. Older age was associated with depression among NCs only (B= 0.028, SE=0.010, t=2.74, p<0.05). Objective sleep measures were not significantly associated with depression in both groups, though there was a trend for shorter total sleep time being associated with worse depression among NCs (B=-.009, SE =.005, p=.067, partial eta-squared=.104). NCs with poor subjective sleep quality had later bedtimes (t=-2.90, p=.006, d =-.91), compared to NCs with good sleep quality. PwS with poor subjective sleep quality had similar objective sleep measures(mean total sleep time, bed-times, wake-time, standard deviation of total sleep time, bed-times and wake-times) when compared to PwS with good sleep quality. Conclusions Our results support that subjective, but not objective, sleep measures are associated with depression. This suggests that depression is more strongly associated with the perception of sleep than to sleep itself - i.e., depression may affect the experience of sleep or ability to recall sleep. Regardless of diagnostic group, more than half of the sample reported poor sleep quality. Moreover, poor subjective sleep quality was only associated with objective sleep measures among NCs. Optimal objective sleep measures likely vary by individuals. Among PwS, effects of medications like antipsychotics and lifestyle differences may affect the quality of sleep, despite maintaining the duration of sleep. Optimizing sleep for PwS should consider factors such as high rates of disability (affecting daily routines), medication usage, and sleeping environments (shared rooms, etc.). Future directions include investigating the impact of antipsychotic medication, effects of untreated obstructive sleep apnea, and nature of longitudinal relationships between sleep and depression on sleep quality.
psychiatry,geriatrics & gerontology,gerontology