Marine ecological and environmental health assessment using the pressure-state-response framework at different spatial scales, China

Wei Yang,Ziyue Zhang,Tao Sun,Haifei Liu,Dongdong Shao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2020.106965
IF: 6.9
2021-02-01
Ecological Indicators
Abstract:<p>Coastal seas are sensitive marine ecosystems, subject to stress from human activities and climate change. Understanding their health is therefore essential. In this study, we developed a comprehensive marine health assessment index (<em>MHI</em>) system using the pressure-state-response framework, and used it to explore the temporal and spatial differences in marine health for 4 Chinese seas and 11 coastal regions of these seas. The South China Sea was relatively healthy, with an average <em>MHI</em> score of 0.72; the other coastal regions were moderately healthy, with <em>MHI</em> of 0.60 for the Yellow Sea, 0.59 for the Bohai Sea, and 0.56 for the East China Sea. At a provincial scale, Hainan's coastal sea was relatively healthy. Guangdong, Shanghai, Tianjin, Liaoning, and Shandong had relatively healthy coastal seas; the others were moderately healthy. The overall health of most seas and provincial coasts decreased from 2003 to 2018. However, <em>MHI</em> increased by 10.6% in the East China Sea, versus 16.4 and 6.7% (respectively) for the Shanghai and Zhejiang coastal seas in the East China Sea, and a decrease of 4.9% for the Fujian coastal sea. The Bohai Sea <em>MHI</em> decreased by 1.6%, but Tianjin's <em>MHI</em> increased by 1.7%. Therefore, the <em>MHI</em> trends were inconsistent between the regional and provincial scales. Marine disasters and environmental factors caused large <em>MHI</em> changes at a regional scale, whereas human factors were more important at the provincial scale. Our results show that an assessment's spatial scale strongly affects the key factors that will be identified. Our results will help marine managers assess marine health at different spatial scales to support marine protection planning.</p>
environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main aim of this paper is to address the issue of ecosystem health assessment in China's coastal waters and to explore the spatiotemporal differences in marine ecological and environmental health at different spatial scales (entire sea area vs. provincial coastal regions). The study employs the Pressure-State-Response (PSR) framework to develop a comprehensive Marine Health Index (MHI) to assess the marine health status of four Chinese sea areas (Bohai Sea, Yellow Sea, East China Sea, South China Sea) and 11 coastal provinces. Specifically, the study addresses the following key issues: 1. **Development of the Assessment System**: A comprehensive assessment index system was designed based on the PSR framework, encompassing the dimensions of pressure, state, and response, to quantify the impact of various factors on marine ecosystem health. 2. **Standardization of Assessment Indicators**: To eliminate differences in dimensions and magnitudes among different indicators, all input data were standardized. 3. **Calculation of Marine Health Index**: By comprehensively considering factors such as natural conditions and human activities, the MHI values for each sea area and its coastal provinces were calculated to assess the health status of marine ecosystems. 4. **Determination of Indicator Weights**: The relative importance of different indicators for the assessment results was determined using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and the Coefficient of Variation (CV) method. 5. **Data Analysis and Results Presentation**: Data from 2003 to 2018 were collected to analyze the trends in pressure, state, and response in different sea areas and provincial coastal regions, and how these changes affect the MHI values. Through the above work, the study reveals the temporal trends in marine health status across different sea areas and coastal provinces, identifies key factors affecting marine health, and emphasizes the importance of spatial scale selection in assessments. These results assist marine managers in evaluating marine health status at different spatial scales and support the formulation of marine conservation plans.