Abstract:In this study, we investigated the performance of flexible trailing edge serrations of various shapes for airfoil self-noise reduction through anechoic wind tunnel experiments. A flat plate model was tested at zero angle of attack. The chord-based Reynolds number was between 1.6 × 105 and 4 × 105. The boundary layers were fully tripped near the leading edge. Add-on type trailing edge serrations were cut from flexible polyethylene terephthalate sheets. It is observed that compared with rigid serrations, flexible serrations can achieve an additional broadband noise reduction up to 2 dB–3 dB at high frequencies, and the effect also depends on the geometry of the serrations. Complementary deformation measurement and aerodynamic force measurement show that flexible serrations can align better with the flow and are expected to reduce the crossflow intensity near the serration roots, which has been related to the extraneous high-frequency noise generated by serrations in previous studies. An inviscid model is proposed to predict the wake structure and the loadings for serrations of various shapes. Although the model over-predicts the crossflow speed due to the omission of the viscous effect, the relative intensity corresponding to different serration geometry is consistent with experimental observations. Last, we show that the recent analytical noise prediction model [B. Lyu and L. J. Ayton, "Rapid noise prediction models for serrated leading and trailing edges," J. Sound Vib. 469, 115136 (2020)] for a serrated trailing edge still significantly overpredicts the noise reduction capacity by serrations and does not reveal the role of serration shape properly. This indicates the necessity to include the non-frozen turbulent properties near serrations in the future prediction models.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper This paper primarily investigates the impact of different shapes and flexibilities of serrations on airfoil trailing edge noise. Specifically, the authors conducted anechoic wind tunnel experiments to test the noise suppression effects of different shapes and flexibilities of serrations on airfoil self-noise at zero angle of attack. The main objectives of the study include: 1. **Evaluating the effectiveness of flexible serrations**: Whether flexible serrations can further reduce broadband noise, especially in the high-frequency range, compared to rigid serrations. 2. **Analyzing the impact of serration shapes**: How different serration geometries (such as sawtooth, iron-shaped, root-cut, and peak-cut) affect noise suppression. 3. **Exploring deformation and aerodynamic measurements**: By measuring the deformation and aerodynamic forces of the serrations, understanding how flexible serrations better align with the flow field to reduce cross-flow intensity, which is believed to cause additional high-frequency noise. 4. **Validating theoretical models**: Proposing an inviscid model to predict the wake structure and load of different serration shapes and comparing it with experimental results to assess the accuracy of existing theoretical models. ### Main Findings 1. **Advantages of flexible serrations**: Flexible serrations can additionally reduce broadband noise by 2 dB to 3 dB in the high-frequency range compared to rigid serrations. 2. **Impact of serration shapes**: Iron-shaped serrations show better noise suppression in the low-frequency range but perform poorly in the high-frequency range. Root-cut serrations perform the worst in the low to mid-frequency range, while peak-cut serrations have similar performance to sawtooth serrations in the low-frequency range but generate slightly higher noise in the high-frequency range. 3. **Deformation and aerodynamic measurements**: Flexible serrations can better align with the flow field, reducing cross-flow intensity and thus lowering high-frequency noise. 4. **Limitations of theoretical models**: Existing theoretical models significantly overestimate the high-frequency noise suppression capability, and future models need to consider the non-frozen effects of near-wall turbulence characteristics. ### Conclusion Through experimental and theoretical analysis, this study reveals the important role of flexible serrations in suppressing airfoil trailing edge noise and points out the shortcomings of existing theoretical models, providing new directions for future noise control research.

A study of the effect of serration shape and flexibility on trailing edge noise

Noise reduction mechanisms for insert-type serrations of the NACA-0012 airfoil

Noise Reduction in Wind Turbine Airfoils with Serrated Trailing Edges: An Experimental Study in Low Turbulence Wind Tunnel

On Improving the Noise Reduction Performance of Trailing Edge Serrations by Extension

Noise Reduction Mechanisms of an Airfoil with Trailing Edge Serrations at Low Mach Number

Effects of trailing-edge serration shape on airfoil noise reduction with zero incidence angle

Effect of streamwise vane treatments on the noise reduction performance of trailing edge serrations under aerodynamic loading conditions

Enhancing the noise reduction capability of the trailing edge serration at incidence using serration extension

The Control of Aerodynamic Sound Due to Boundary Layer Pressure Gust Scattering by Trailing Edge Serrations

An experimental investigation of aerodynamic and aeroacoustic performance of a wind turbine airfoil with trailing edge serrations

On the noise prediction for serrated leading edges

Numerical study of trailing-edge noise reduction mechanism of wind turbine with a novel trailing-edge serration

An Analysis on the Flow Field Structures and the Aerodynamic Noise of Airfoils with Serrated Trailing Edges Based on Embedded Large Eddy Flow Simulations

Numerical Analysis of Broadband Noise Generated by an Airfoil with Spanwise-Varying Leading Edges

Enhancing the noise reduction capability of serrations usinglow-profile vortex generators

Flow topology and noise modeling of trailing edge serrations

Effect of sawtooth trailing edge serrations on the reductions of airfoil broadband noise

Analysis of wavy leading-edge noise reduction and source mechanism in rod-airfoil interactions

Effect of trailing-edge serrations on noise reduction in a coupled bionic aerofoil inspired by barn owls

Noise reduction and aerodynamics of isolated multi-copter rotors with serrated trailing edges during forward flight

Experimental Study of the Performance of a Propeller with Trailing-Edge Serrations