Abstract:Background Metagenome-assembled viral genomes have significantly advanced the discovery and characterization of the human gut virome. However, we lack a comparative assessment of assembly tools on the efficacy of viral genome identification, particularly across Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) and Third Generation Sequencing (TGS) data. Results We evaluated the efficiency of NGS, TGS and hybrid assemblers for viral genome discovery using 95 viral-like particle (VLP) enriched fecal samples sequenced on both Illumina and PacBio platforms. MEGAHIT, metaFlye and hybridSPAdes emerged as the optimal choices for NGS, TGS and hybrid datasets, respectively. Notably, these assemblers produced distinctive viral genomes, demonstrating a remarkable degree of complementarity. By combining individual assembler results, we expanded the total number of non-redundant high-quality viral genomes by 4.83 ~ 21.7 fold compared to individual assemblers. Among them, viral genomes from NGS and TGS data have the least overlap, indicating the impact of data type on viral genome recovery. We also evaluated four binning methods, finding that CONCOCT incorporated more unrelated contigs into the same bins, while MetaBAT2, AVAMB and vRhyme balanced inclusiveness and taxonomic consistency within bins. Conclusions Our findings highlight the challenges in metagenome-driven viral discovery, underscoring tool limitations. We advocate for combined use of multiple assemblers and sequencing technologies when feasible and highlight the urgent need for specialized tools tailored to gut virome assembly. This study contributes essential insights for advancing viral genome research in the context of gut metagenomics.

ViromeFlowX: a Comprehensive Nextflow-based Automated Workflow for Mining Viral Genomes from Metagenomic Sequencing Data

FastViromeExplorer: a Pipeline for Virus and Phage Identification and Abundance Profiling in Metagenomics Data

Fast Virome Explorer: A Pipeline for Virus and Phage Identification and Abundance Profiling in Metagenomics Data

VIGA: a one-stop tool for eukaryotic virus identification and genome assembly from next-generation-sequencing data

VirID: Beyond Virus Discovery - An Integrated Platform for Comprehensive RNA Virus Characterization

VITAP: A High Precision Tool for DNA and RNA Viral Classification Based On Meta-omic Data

Accurate viral genome reconstruction and host assignment with proximity-ligation sequencing

drVM: a new tool for efficient genome assembly of known eukaryotic viruses from metagenomes

Ten computational challenges in human virome studies

iVirP: An integrative, efficient, and user-friendly pipeline to annotate viral contigs from raw reads of metagenome or VLP sequencing

An Introduction to Next Generation Sequencing Bioinformatic Analysis in Gut Microbiome Studies

FastViromeExplorer-Novel: Recovering Draft Genomes of Novel Viruses and Phages in Metagenomic Data.

An Integrated Software for Virus Community Sequencing Data Analysis

DVsc: An Automated Framework for Efficiently Detecting Viral Infection from Single-cell Transcriptomics Data

Identifying viruses from metagenomic data by deep learning

TheViral MetaGenome Annotation Pipeline(VMGAP):an automated tool for the functional annotation of viral Metagenomic shotgun sequencing data

Unlocking the Viral Universe: Metagenomic Analysis of Bat Samples Using Next-Generation Sequencing

Complementary Insights into Gut Viral Genomes: a Comparative Benchmark of Short- and Long-Read Metagenomes Using Diverse Assemblers and Binners

Using artificial intelligence to document the hidden RNA virosphere

Extraordinary diversity of viruses in deep‐sea sediments as revealed by metagenomics without prior virion separation